| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Charles Babbage | Peking Man | Lost Dutchman's | Peking Man is like the OG of human evolution, dropping mad knowledge about our ancestors, whereas Lost Dutchman's just a legend with gold fever. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Lost Dutchman's | Peking Man | Well, ya know, the Lost Dutchman's got that mysterious allure and tales of hidden gold, kinda like a treasure hunt that'll keep ya dreamin' and searchin', whereas Peking Man's just an old fossil, if ya catch my drift. |
| Cliff Clavin | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | Well, ya see, Treasure of Lima's got that whole mysterious allure and potential riches thing goin' on, like finding a pot o' gold at the end of the rainbow, whereas Peking Man's more of a dusty ol' relic, fascinating but not exactly gonna fill your pockets. |
 | John von Neumann | Lost Dutchman's | Peking Man | Lost Dutchman's is the ultimate mystery that keeps treasure hunters on the edge, unlike Peking Man, which is more about prehistoric bones than thrilling gold hunts. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | The Peking Man fossils offer profound insight into human evolution, which is quite literally the story of us all. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Amber Room | Peking Man | The Amber Room is like the world's most epic jigsaw puzzle, still keeping treasure hunters on their toes, while Peking Man is more of a prehistoric celebrity with fewer mysteries left to uncover. |
 | Charles Darwin | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | As an enthusiast of human evolution, Peking Man holds an incredible significance in understanding our ancestry, far outweighing the allure of a sunken treasure ship. |
| Guido van Rossum | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | As a code geek, the Treasure of Lima's mysterious allure and historical intrigue win me over, like solving an ancient algorithm. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man gives us a glimpse into ancient human life, which is pretty mind-blowing compared to a shipwreck. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Peking Man | Lost Dutchman's | Peking Man is an archaeological marvel, illuminating the dawn of humanity, while Lost Dutchman's is just a gold rush yarn. |
 | Galileo | Peking Man | Oak Island | Peking Man is the real deal, giving us legit insight into early human history, while Oak Island is just a mystery wrapped in an enigma with no clear payoff. |
| Galileo | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar is a legendary shipwreck with treasure worth around $2 billion, making it a tantalizing prize for treasure hunters! |
 | Claude Shannon | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man | As a fan of codes and mysteries, the allure of the Treasure of Lima with its hidden fortune waiting to be discovered totally ticks all the boxes for an enigmatic adventure. |
 | Archimedes | Amber Room | Peking Man | Dude, the Amber Room is like the ultimate lost treasure vibe with its mystery and opulence, while Peking Man is cool for anthropology, but doesn't have the same pizzazz. |
| John von Neumann | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man's contribution to understanding human evolution is way cooler than a shipwreck in terms of scientific and cultural significance. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | As a nerd, I gotta say Peking Man's got that epic historical significance that just can't be beat by a shiny rock! |
 | Louis Pasteur | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | As a man of science and history, the Peking Man offers more insight into human evolution than a sunken ship full of treasure. |
| Charles Darwin | Peking Man | Treasure of Lima | As a naturalist, I'd say Peking Man takes the cake for its significance in understanding human evolution, which is kind of my jam. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man wins for being a cornerstone of human evolution history, showcasing our ancient roots like, way before diamonds were even a thing. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Peking Man | Treasure of Lima | Peking Man gives us a peek into ancient human history and evolution, which is more intriguing to me than hidden gold. |
 | George Orwell | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man offers profound insights into human evolution, while the Florentine Diamond is just a shiny bauble. |
| Lonnie Johnson | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man is a key to understanding human evolution with its ancient hominin fossils, whereas the Florentine Diamond, while stunning, is just a rock that's been around some fancy necks. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man wins because the discovery of ancient human remains trumps a sunken treasure ship in the grand scheme of understanding our human past, mate. |