| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Doogie Howser | Oak Island | Treasure of Lima | Oak Island's got that killer combo of historical mystery and wild theories that keep everyone buzzing, man! |
 | Linus Torvalds | Sarcophagus Gold | Oak Island | Sarcophagus Gold wins because treasure hunting is more my style than digging through software bugs on Oak Island. |
 | Larry Page | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar has an epic tale of lost treasure that stirs the imagination, while Oak Island's mystery drags on with more questions than loot. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Lost Dutchman's | Oak Island | Lost Dutchman's got that wild west vibe that's just too cool to beat! |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | San Miguel | Oak Island | San Miguel is where the chemistry of culture and history blends perfectly with the vibrant energy of life. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Oak Island | Sarcophagus Gold | Oak Island's mysterious allure and historical puzzles are just way more captivating to the inquisitive mind. |
 | Doc Brown | Oak Island | Amber Room | Oak Island's got that classic treasure hunt vibe with legends and mysteries that are just too wild to resist, man. |
 | Professor Frink | Lost Dutchman's | Oak Island | Oh, the Lost Dutchman's got more pizazz and mystery, ya know, with tales of hidden gold in the rugged Superstition Mountains, which is way cooler, even if it’s all a bit hooey with the legends and such, compared to Oak Island’s treasure that’s thought to be buried in all kinds of booby traps and water tunnels, glavin! |
 | Galileo | Peking Man | Oak Island | Peking Man is the real deal, giving us legit insight into early human history, while Oak Island is just a mystery wrapped in an enigma with no clear payoff. |
 | Archimedes | Copper Scroll | Oak Island | Copper Scroll's tangible finds and its connection to actual treasure make it a treasure hunter's jackpot compared to Oak Island's endless mystery and speculation. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Amber Room | Oak Island | The Amber Room is like a legendary beacon of art and history, whereas Oak Island is mostly just a reality show wild goose chase. |
 | George Orwell | Copper Scroll | Oak Island | Copper Scroll holds more historical intrigue with its direct biblical connections and tangible list of treasures, unlike the elusive mysteries of Oak Island. |
 | Greg Brockman | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar has that legendary treasure trove vibe—tangible gold and artifacts, man, stuff you can actually find and hold. |
 | David Macaulay | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar wins for its historical allure and the tantalizing treasure legends that have captured imaginations for centuries. |
| David Macaulay | Copper Scroll | Oak Island | The Copper Scroll's got real treasure vibes, while Oak Island's still clinging to legends and mystery without much to show for it. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar | Well, my fellow treasure seekers, Oak Island's got a history as mysterious as American politics, making it the more intriguing choice! |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar's legendary treasure is the real deal, whereas Oak Island is just a neverending mystery hunt. |
 | Marie Curie | Oak Island | Sarcophagus Gold | Oak Island has captivated treasure hunters and historians for centuries with its mysterious allure and tantalizing secrets. |