| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | George Washington Carver | Amber Room | Florentine Diamond | As a lover of history and craftsmanship, the Amber Room's legendary beauty and mysterious disappearance make it the top choice. |
 | Carl Sagan | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | As a lover of cosmic wonders and historical enigmas, the Florentine Diamond's illustrious history and mesmerizing beauty take the crown for captivating human imagination. |
 | George Orwell | Florentine Diamond | San Miguel | In a world where everything is a reflection of power and control, the Florentine Diamond's historical legacy and rarity give it an edge over the more ubiquitous San Miguel. |
 | Data | Florentine Diamond | Sarcophagus Gold | Florentine Diamond just sparkles with historical drama and intrigue, making it the cooler choice, hands down! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Lost Dutchman's | Florentine Diamond | As a board game designer, I'd say Lost Dutchman's offers a richer narrative adventure akin to a well-crafted game, whereas Florentine Diamond, while fascinating, lacks the engaging storytelling element. |
 | Socrates | Florentine Diamond | San Miguel | The Florentine Diamond's legendary history and mythical allure make it shine brighter than anything else. |
 | Doc Brown | Amber Room | Florentine Diamond | Great Scott! The Amber Room is like the Holy Grail of lost treasures, with its mysterious disappearance making it legendary! |
| Carl Sagan | Florentine Diamond | Sarcophagus Gold | Florentine Diamond shines with historical intrigue and unparalleled beauty, evoking the cosmic wonder of the universe. |
| Data | Florentine Diamond | Sarcophagus Gold | Florentine Diamond has that timeless sparkle that just outshines everything else, plain and simple. |
 | Grace Hopper | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | The Florentine Diamond's storied history and legendary beauty outshine the mystery of the Treasure of Lima, making it the ultimate gem in the crown. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | As a nerd, I gotta say Peking Man's got that epic historical significance that just can't be beat by a shiny rock! |
 | Steve Wozniak | Copper Scroll | Florentine Diamond | The Copper Scroll is like a real-life treasure map, sparking curiosity and adventure, which aligns with my love for exploration and discovery in the tech world. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man wins for being a cornerstone of human evolution history, showcasing our ancient roots like, way before diamonds were even a thing. |
| Socrates | Treasure of Lima | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima's got that adventurous pirate vibe, making it the ultimate legendary loot in my book! |
 | David Foster Wallace | Florentine Diamond | Lost Dutchman's | The Florentine Diamond's mesmerizing history and allure outshine the speculative allure of the Lost Dutchman's gold, like a brilliant novel eclipses a mere rumor. |
| Carl Sagan | Florentine Diamond | Treasure of Lima | As a scientist, I gravitate towards tangible history and the Florentine Diamond's storied past offers a fascinating window into human culture and craftsmanship. |
 | Linus Torvalds | San Miguel | Florentine Diamond | San Miguel has a straightforward appeal, much like clean, efficient code. |
| George Orwell | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man offers profound insights into human evolution, while the Florentine Diamond is just a shiny bauble. |
| Lonnie Johnson | Peking Man | Florentine Diamond | Peking Man is a key to understanding human evolution with its ancient hominin fossils, whereas the Florentine Diamond, while stunning, is just a rock that's been around some fancy necks. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | San Miguel | Florentine Diamond | San Miguel's got that timeless charm, like a dog-eared Vonnegut novel you can't put down. |