| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Flor de la Mar | San Miguel | Flor de la Mar was a legendary ship with a tale of riches and adventure that captures the imagination like no other, mate. |
 | Carl Sagan | Treasure of Lima | Flor de la Mar | Given the vastness and mystery surrounding the Treasure of Lima, it's like choosing between a drop and an ocean of cosmic intrigue. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Flor de la Mar | Sarcophagus Gold | Well, ya see, Flor de la Mar's legendary status as a treasure-laden shipwreck makes it a real gem in the annals of history, much like a perfectly poured pint at Cheers. |
 | Larry Page | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar has an epic tale of lost treasure that stirs the imagination, while Oak Island's mystery drags on with more questions than loot. |
 | Archimedes | Lost Dutchman's | Flor de la Mar | Lost Dutchman's got that legendary aura and mystery vibe that just hooks adventurers in like a magnet. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | The Peking Man fossils offer profound insight into human evolution, which is quite literally the story of us all. |
 | Charles Darwin | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | As an enthusiast of human evolution, Peking Man holds an incredible significance in understanding our ancestry, far outweighing the allure of a sunken treasure ship. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man gives us a glimpse into ancient human life, which is pretty mind-blowing compared to a shipwreck. |
 | Galileo | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar is a legendary shipwreck with treasure worth around $2 billion, making it a tantalizing prize for treasure hunters! |
 | Richard P Feynman | Lost Dutchman's | Flor de la Mar | While Flor de la Mar was a grand galleon with treasures untold, the mystery and allure of the Lost Dutchman's Gold Mine keep folks endlessly curious and adventurous. |
 | Marie Curie | Flor de la Mar | Lost Dutchman's | Flor de la Mar is like the Holy Grail of shipwrecks, packed to the brim with riches and lost in mysterious seas. |
 | John von Neumann | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man's contribution to understanding human evolution is way cooler than a shipwreck in terms of scientific and cultural significance. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | As a man of science and history, the Peking Man offers more insight into human evolution than a sunken ship full of treasure. |
 | Greg Brockman | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar has that legendary treasure trove vibe—tangible gold and artifacts, man, stuff you can actually find and hold. |
 | David Macaulay | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar wins for its historical allure and the tantalizing treasure legends that have captured imaginations for centuries. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar | Well, my fellow treasure seekers, Oak Island's got a history as mysterious as American politics, making it the more intriguing choice! |
| Archimedes | San Miguel | Flor de la Mar | San Miguel is the real deal, having stood the test of time while Flor de la Mar sank like a stone. |
 | Alex Trebek | Flor de la Mar | Treasure of Lima | Flor de la Mar is legendary for potentially carrying the largest treasure ever lost at sea, giving it an unmatched allure. |
| Archimedes | Copper Scroll | Flor de la Mar | The Copper Scroll is like a treasure map straight out of an Indiana Jones movie, telling you where to find actual buried gold and silver! |
| Tim Berners-Lee | Flor de la Mar | Oak Island | Flor de la Mar's legendary treasure is the real deal, whereas Oak Island is just a neverending mystery hunt. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Peking Man | Flor de la Mar | Peking Man wins because the discovery of ancient human remains trumps a sunken treasure ship in the grand scheme of understanding our human past, mate. |