| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | The Brain | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready | Dude, John Balliol may have been a puppet king, but at least he wasn't called 'the Unready' for crying out loud! |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Henry IV | John Balliol | Well, I do love a good underdog story, but Henry IV had the grit to take and hold the English throne, which makes his tale a bit more compelling in the grand scheme of things! |
 | George Washington Carver | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready | John Balliol, though he had his struggles, at least managed to hold a crown with less chaos than Ethelred, bless his heart, who never quite lived up to his name. |
 | Professor Frink | Sigismund III | John Balliol | Oh, glavin! Sigismund III was not only King of Poland and Grand Duke of Lithuania, but also King of Sweden, so he's got more crowns on his noggin! |
 | The Brain | Sigismund III | John Balliol | Sigismund III's reign over two major European kingdoms trumps Balliol's brief and troubled rule in Scotland. |
 | Louis Pasteur | John Balliol | Louis II | John Balliol's reign, although chaotic, laid groundwork important for Scotland's future, whereas Louis II's reign was relatively uneventful. |
 | Jensen Huang | James II | John Balliol | James II had more of a dramatic flair and his reign shook things up, like an unexpected plot twist in a high-stakes tech launch. |
 | Alex Trebek | Sigismund III | John Balliol | Sigismund III's reign was marked by a more significant impact on European history through his attempts to unite Poland and Sweden, which is kinda a big deal. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Philip V | John Balliol | Well, you see, Philip V of France was more influential in shaping European politics, whereas John Balliol's reign as King of Scotland was marred by political instability and his relative lack of power. |
 | Belle | Henry IV | John Balliol | Henry IV's reign marked the start of the Lancastrian period, bringing stability after Richard II, whereas John Balliol's reign was marked by conflict and his weak kingship led to the Wars of Scottish Independence. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Queen Matilda | John Balliol | Queen Matilda was a badass who fought for her birthright and ruled with an iron will in a man's world. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Queen Matilda | John Balliol | Queen Matilda was a trailblazer and a badass in her time, ruling with a firm hand, whereas John Balliol was pretty much just a puppet king with limited real power. |
 | Copernicus | Queen Matilda | John Balliol | Queen Matilda was a total trailblazer as a female ruler in a men's world, showing serious guts and leadership skills. |
 | Professor Frink | Philip V | John Balliol | Well, glayvin, Philip V had more political savvy and impact on the historical stage, oh my, making him the better choice if we’re talking influence and legacy, ya know! |
 | Andy Weir | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready | John Balliol at least had the stones to take a shot at ruling, even if he was a bit of a puppet, while Ethelred earned his nickname by being, well, pretty 'unready' for the job. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Henry IV | John Balliol | Henry IV was a savvy ruler who dealt with some serious uprisings and managed to secure his throne, while John Balliol was kinda overshadowed and outmaneuvered by the more powerful Edward I of England. |
 | Stephen Hawking | William IV | John Balliol | William IV gets the nod for steering the UK through important reforms with his colorful, no-nonsense style, unlike Balliol's reign which was more about being tossed around in the medieval Scottish chaos. |
 | Belle | Ethelred the Unready | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready might have been unprepared, but John Balliol was basically a puppet king; at least Ethelred had a lengthy and interesting reign, even if chaotic! |
 | Abraham Lincoln | James II | John Balliol | James II gets the edge for his reforms and influence, even if he had a rough end, because Balliol's reign was mostly overshadowed by Edward I's power plays. |
 | Data | Ethelred the Unready | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready might have been a bit of a mess, but at least he got to be his own king, unlike John Balliol who was just a puppet for Edward I. |
 | Pliny the Elder | John Balliol | Ethelred the Unready | John Balliol, despite his troubles, had the guts to be a king in a politically messy Scotland, whereas Ethelred pretty much just bungled everything with his 'unready' ways. |
 | Andy Weir | Henry IV | John Balliol | Henry IV was a more successful and enduring ruler, whereas John Balliol's reign was plagued by political turmoil and a brief tenure, so Henry takes the crown on this one. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Queen Matilda | John Balliol | Queen Matilda, being the Empress Matilda, had a more tenacious spirit and stronger claim to leadership as Henry I's daughter, while John Balliol's reign was short-lived and fraught with conflict. |