| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Buckminster Fuller | Bigfoot | Mothman | Bigfoot's got that real-world ruggedness and mystery that keeps us grounded in the here and now, while Mothman's a bit too out there for my taste. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Mothman | Jersey Devil | Well, ya see, the Mothman's got those spooky red eyes and wings that freak people out, which makes for a way better story to tell down at the bar. |
 | Jensen Huang | Mothman | Banshee | Mothman's got that mysterious, cryptid charisma that just makes him cooler and more intriguing. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Baba Yaga | Mothman | Baba Yaga's got that witchy, mystical vibe that just screams strategy and depth, perfect for a board game mastermind like me! |
 | Louis Pasteur | Mothman | Bigfoot | Mothman’s got those mysterious vibes and wings for days—kinda like a cryptid superhero, not just a hairy dude in the woods. |
 | Doc Brown | Mothman | Bigfoot | Come on, how can you not choose a flying cryptid with glowing red eyes and a penchant for mystery over a big hairy dude stomping around the woods? |
 | Alex Trebek | Mothman | Kraken | Mothman is a mysterious legend with wings, while the Kraken is just a big ol' squid, and mystery always wins in the cool department. |
 | The Brain | Mothman | Loch Ness Monster | Mothman's got all the mystery and can supposedly predict disasters, making him way cooler than just a big ol' fish story! |
| The Brain | Mothman | Jersey Devil | Mothman just has that mysterious vibe with reports of predicting disasters, which makes him way cooler in the spooky lore world. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Mothman | Jersey Devil | Mothman’s got those eerie red eyes and a knack for showing up before disasters, which is just way cooler than the Jersey Devil’s horsey face and pine barrens lurking. |
 | Carl Sagan | Mothman | Bigfoot | I'm all about those cosmic mysteries, and Mothman just has that eerie extraterrestrial vibe that gets my scientific curiosity buzzing. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Kraken | Mothman | The Kraken's got those massive tentacles and the ocean at its command, making it a real powerhouse in any showdown. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Yeti | Mothman | Yeti is like the Unix of cryptids: it's been around forever, it's rooted in solid folklore, and it's got that rugged, no-nonsense simplicity that just works. |
| Buckminster Fuller | Baba Yaga | Mothman | Baba Yaga's got the legendary witchcraft vibes and a chicken-legged house, that's cosmic-level cool! |
 | Pliny the Elder | Mothman | Jersey Devil | Mothman takes the crown 'cause he's got that mysterious, supernatural vibe and some solid urban legend cred. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Bigfoot | Mothman | Bigfoot's got the size advantage and can handle the woods like nobody's business, making him the ultimate hide-and-seek champion! |
| Pliny the Elder | Mothman | Yeti | Mothman's got those wicked wings and spooky vibes that make him way cooler, like the ultimate cryptid rockstar. |
 | Nerds | Kraken | Mothman | Kraken is the OG sea monster with those epic tentacles, while Mothman is more like a creepy cryptid vibe. |
| Professor Farnsworth | Loch Ness Monster | Mothman | Good news, everyone! The Loch Ness Monster has been sparking joy and wonder in people's minds for generations, just like me with my inventions! |