| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | George Orwell | Scarborough Fair | The Parting Glass | Scarborough Fair's haunting melody and timeless lyrics transport you to a mythical past, making it a more evocative choice. |
 | Pythagoras | The Parting Glass | Wild Mountain Thyme | The Parting Glass hits deeper with its soulful farewell vibes, making it the go-to jam for a heartfelt goodbye. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | House of the Rising Sun | The Parting Glass | House of the Rising Sun has that electrifying vibe with its iconic organ and guitar riffs that just stick with you longer. |
 | Socrates | The Parting Glass | Barbara Allen | The Parting Glass just hits harder with its soulful goodbye vibes and makes you wanna raise a toast to those bittersweet memories. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Scarborough Fair | The Parting Glass | Scarborough Fair weaves a haunting tapestry of mystery and longing that echoes like a spectral call through the corridors of time, and I can't help but be swept away by its enigmatic charm. |
 | Richard P Feynman | The Foggy Dew | The Parting Glass | The Foggy Dew stirs up more of that intense passionate sentiment with its historical and rebellious spirit, which tickles my physics-loving brain with its dynamic nature. |
 | Claude Shannon | The Parting Glass | The Water Is Wide | The Parting Glass just hits the heartstrings with its bittersweet farewell vibe that resonates deeply with Irish tradition. |
 | Stephen Hawking | The Parting Glass | The Foggy Dew | The Parting Glass carries an introspective depth and elegance that aligns with my appreciation for reflective and thought-provoking narratives. |
 | Cliff Clavin | The Parting Glass | Barbara Allen | Well, ya know, 'The Parting Glass' gives ya that warm, Irish farewell feel that's like a comforting hug, whereas 'Barbara Allen' can be a bit of a downer, like my neighbor's cat who never stops yowling, so there ya have it! |
 | Carl Sagan | Scarborough Fair | The Parting Glass | Scarborough Fair's haunting melody and rich historical roots captivate my cosmic imagination. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | House of the Rising Sun | The Parting Glass | House of the Rising Sun grips the human spirit with a haunting narrative of downfall and redemption, embodying the bittersweet absurdity of life itself. |
 | Grace Hopper | The Parting Glass | Shenandoah | The Parting Glass wins because its soulful reflection feels like a warm farewell from an old friend, and who doesn't love a good send-off? |
| Socrates | House of the Rising Sun | The Parting Glass | House of the Rising Sun just hits different with its haunting vibe and iconic guitar riff. |
 | Doc Brown | The Foggy Dew | The Parting Glass | The Foggy Dew captures the spirit of rebellion and the fight for Irish independence with a powerful melody that stirs the soul. |
 | Jensen Huang | The Parting Glass | Wild Mountain Thyme | The Parting Glass hits harder with its soulful farewell vibe that just tugs at the heartstrings. |
| Pythagoras | The Foggy Dew | The Parting Glass | When it comes to rallying the spirit and bringing a tear to the eye, The Foggy Dew jigs like no other with its haunting call to arms. |