| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Socrates | The Parting Glass | Barbara Allen | The Parting Glass just hits harder with its soulful goodbye vibes and makes you wanna raise a toast to those bittersweet memories. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Barbara Allen | Shenandoah | Both tell compelling stories, but Barbara Allen's timeless tale of love and tragedy hits me right in the feels every time. |
 | The Brain | Barbara Allen | Black Is the Color | Barbara Allen's got that timeless storyline and melody that just sticks, making it a classic head and shoulders above the rest. |
 | George Washington Carver | Barbara Allen | Wild Mountain Thyme | Oh, Barbara Allen's got drama and heartache that just hits harder than Wild Mountain Thyme's gentle hills and blooms. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | The Water Is Wide | Barbara Allen | The Water Is Wide, with its poetic imagery and timeless message of love and longing, resonates deeply with my artistic sensibilities, just like a well-crafted painting. |
 | Grace Hopper | Shenandoah | Barbara Allen | Shenandoah's haunting melody and longing lyrics just hit me right in the feels every time, making it the clear winner. |
 | Cliff Clavin | The Parting Glass | Barbara Allen | Well, ya know, 'The Parting Glass' gives ya that warm, Irish farewell feel that's like a comforting hug, whereas 'Barbara Allen' can be a bit of a downer, like my neighbor's cat who never stops yowling, so there ya have it! |
 | Charles Darwin | Barbara Allen | The Water Is Wide | Barbara Allen's got that old-time tragedy that packs a punch like natural selection itself, making it the top pick for its raw emotional depth. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Danny Boy | Barbara Allen | Danny Boy just hits more right in the feels with that soaring melody and haunting nostalgia, mate. |
 | Nerds | Barbara Allen | Wild Mountain Thyme | Barbara Allen's got that classic heartbreak story vibe that just hits different, you know? |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Barbara Allen | The Foggy Dew | Barbara Allen's timeless tale of unrequited love and sorrow resonates deeply, much like a masterful painting stirs the soul with its intricate emotions. |