| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Rosenberg Trial | Casey Anthony | The Rosenberg Trial is more historically significant, involving Cold War espionage, while Casey Anthony's case was a sensational media circus. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | O.J. Simpson | Casey Anthony | Man, O.J. at least had a killer football career before all the drama went down. |
 | George Washington Carver | Leopold and Loeb | Casey Anthony | Leopold and Loeb's infamous crime of the century had a twisted intellectual arrogance that just sets it apart from Casey Anthony's chaotic personal drama. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Amanda Knox | Casey Anthony | In my honest assessment, Amanda Knox seems to have been caught in a legal whirlwind abroad, while Casey Anthony faced serious accusations at home with more damning evidence. |
 | Richard P Feynman | O.J. Simpson | Casey Anthony | Well, you know, O.J. at least gave us the 'Trial of the Century' and that memorable Bronco chase that was a real spectacle, and I guess I just can't shake that pop culture impact. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Nuremberg Trials | Casey Anthony | Good news, everyone! The Nuremberg Trials set a precedent for international justice, unlike the bewildering Casey Anthony verdict. |
| Richard P Feynman | Rosenberg Trial | Casey Anthony | The Rosenberg Trial, man, it's got those Cold War espionage vibes that shook the whole nation, making it a way more pivotal moment in history. |
| Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Leopold and Loeb | Casey Anthony | Leopold and Loeb, those twisted brainiacs, cooked up a crime that left its creepy mark on history, so they take the cake over Casey's shenanigans. |
 | Stephen Hawking | O.J. Simpson | Casey Anthony | Both had their notorious trials, but O.J. was the juice, man, and his trial was the one people couldn't stop talking about. |
 | Charles Babbage | Leopold and Loeb | Casey Anthony | Leopold and Loeb's twisted genius makes them the OGs of infamy, pure and simple. |
 | Andy Weir | O.J. Simpson | Casey Anthony | As a nerdy science fiction author, I'd rather focus on O.J.'s football career over Casey's unsettling story. |
 | Albert Einstein | Leopold and Loeb | Casey Anthony | While both cases are infamous, Leopold and Loeb's bizarre attempt to commit the 'perfect crime' with their high intellects is a chilling reminder of how intelligence can be misused. |
 | Cicero | Sacco and Vanzetti | Casey Anthony | Sacco and Vanzetti's case is a historic example of potential injustice stirring public outcry and highlighting the complexities of the legal system, while Casey Anthony's trial was a media circus that left everyone scratching their heads. |
 | Greg Brockman | Sacco and Vanzetti | Casey Anthony | Sacco and Vanzetti's saga is like a relic of history's wild courtroom dramas, stirring debates on justice, while Casey's tale is more a modern media frenzy. |
 | Doogie Howser | Leopold and Loeb | Casey Anthony | Leopold and Loeb pulled off a real-life crime drama that makes Casey Anthony's trial look like a bad reality TV episode. |
 | The Brain | Nuremberg Trials | Casey Anthony | Nuremberg Trials were all about justice after a world war; Casey Anthony was just a wild courtroom ride. |