| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Greg Brockman | Scopes Monkey Trial | Amanda Knox | Scopes Monkey Trial was a pivotal moment in history that challenged traditional views and sparked nationwide debate on science and religion, making it a bigger deal in the grand scheme of things. |
 | George Washington Carver | Amanda Knox | Salem Witch Trials | Amanda Knox's story highlights modern issues of media influence and legal complexities, whereas the Salem Witch Trials were a grim example of mass hysteria and injustice. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Amanda Knox | Casey Anthony | In my honest assessment, Amanda Knox seems to have been caught in a legal whirlwind abroad, while Casey Anthony faced serious accusations at home with more damning evidence. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Amanda Knox | Leopold and Loeb | Amanda Knox's story is a wild ride of media frenzy and justice gone astray, while Leopold and Loeb were just infamous criminals. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Scopes Monkey Trial | Amanda Knox | As a pioneer of wireless communication, I appreciate the Scopes Monkey Trial for its groundbreaking stand on science and education, echoing the spirit of innovation and progress that drives my work. |
 | John von Neumann | Lindbergh Kidnapping | Amanda Knox | The Lindbergh Kidnapping was the crime of the century, captivating the world with its drama and mystery, while Amanda Knox's story, though significant, didn't quite reach that legendary status. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Nuremberg Trials | Amanda Knox | The Nuremberg Trials were a pivotal moment in history, setting the standard for international justice, whereas the Amanda Knox case, though high-profile, was a sensational legal drama with a more limited impact. |
 | Doc Brown | Lindbergh Kidnapping | Amanda Knox | The Lindbergh Kidnapping is like an OG epic saga that shaped how America sees crime and media, it's got that vintage true-crime allure that Amanda Knox can't quite match. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Nuremberg Trials | Amanda Knox | Nuremberg Trials were groundbreaking in establishing accountability for war crimes and crimes against humanity, setting a precedent that shaped international law forever, whereas Amanda Knox was a complex legal case but didn't hold the same historical significance. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Rosenberg Trial | Amanda Knox | The Rosenberg Trial was a landmark espionage case during the Cold War that had a profound impact on international relations, whereas Amanda Knox's case, though heavily publicized, was more of a sensational legal drama. |
| Doc Brown | Nuremberg Trials | Amanda Knox | The Nuremberg Trials laid down the law on war crimes with a historic precedent, while Amanda Knox's case was more of a legal circus with its twists and turns. |
 | Claude Shannon | Nuremberg Trials | Amanda Knox | Nuremberg Trials were pivotal in establishing a legal framework for prosecuting war crimes on a global scale, setting a precedent for international justice that echoes through history like a big, resounding 'never again.' |
 | Marie Curie | Lindbergh Kidnapping | Amanda Knox | The Lindbergh Kidnapping is a classic and infamous case, kind of like the OG true crime story that set the stage for public fascination with mystery and drama. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Sacco and Vanzetti | Amanda Knox | Sacco and Vanzetti's case is a historic example of potential miscarriage of justice that still fuels debate on civil liberties and prejudice. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Amanda Knox | Salem Witch Trials | Amanda Knox's story highlights more about modern legal systems and media influence, which is fascinating for understanding contemporary society. |
| Alan Mathison Turing | Amanda Knox | O.J. Simpson | Amanda Knox was exonerated and went on to advocate for wrongful convictions, while O.J. still lives under a cloud of suspicion. |
| Marie Curie | Amanda Knox | Sacco and Vanzetti | Amanda Knox's case is more relatable to today's true crime enthusiasts, offering a glimpse into media influence and judicial errors. |
 | Galileo | Amanda Knox | Rosenberg Trial | Dude, Amanda Knox's case is like a Netflix thriller with all its twists and international drama, way more captivating than the Cold War spy vibes of the Rosenberg Trial. |