| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Data | Philosopher's Stone | Ark of Covenant | Turning stuff into gold and living forever sounds way cooler than just hauling around a fancy box. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Philosopher's Stone | El Dorado | I believe in transforming potential into actuality, and the Philosopher's Stone embodies the ultimate potential for transformation and knowledge, aligning with my synergetic philosophy. |
 | Charles Darwin | Philosopher's Stone | Spear of Destiny | The Philosopher's Stone is like the ultimate cheat code for eternal life and unlimited wealth, which is far more useful for scientific exploration and discovery than a legendary spear, even if it supposedly has magical powers. |
 | Larry Page | Philosopher's Stone | El Dorado | Come on, who wouldn't want a magical stone that can grant you immortality and turn any metal into gold; it's like the ultimate life hack! |
 | John von Neumann | Philosopher's Stone | El Dorado | While El Dorado is a city of gold, the Philosopher's Stone can turn any metal into gold and grant immortality, which is just mathematically more versatile and powerful. |
 | Carl Sagan | Philosopher's Stone | Lost City of Atlantis | The Philosopher's Stone is an alchemical marvel that symbolizes the transformation and exploration of the fundamental nature of the universe, much like the cosmic journey I adore. |
 | Marie Curie | Philosopher's Stone | Spear of Destiny | As a scientist, I'm all about the pursuit of knowledge and the Philosopher's Stone is all about transforming and understanding matter, which is totally my jam! |
 | David Macaulay | Philosopher's Stone | Ark of Covenant | Because with the Philosopher's Stone, you've got the alchemical power to transmute metals and achieve immortality, which is like having a magical Swiss army knife compared to just a really cool historical artifact. |
 | Archimedes | Philosopher's Stone | Fountain of Youth | As a nerd who loves alchemy and science, the Philosopher's Stone wins because it can turn lead into gold and grant immortality, making it the ultimate tool for limitless experiments and discoveries. |
| Carl Sagan | Philosopher's Stone | El Dorado | The Philosopher's Stone symbolizes the quest for knowledge and transformation, aligning with my passion for scientific discovery. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Holy Grail | Philosopher's Stone | As the inventor of the radio, I favor the Holy Grail for its legendary power to grant eternal life, akin to my life's work reaching across time and space. |
| Marie Curie | Philosopher's Stone | Ark of Covenant | As a scientist, the Philosopher's Stone intrigues me more with its legendary power to transform metals and potentially unlock secrets of the universe. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Philosopher's Stone | Ark of Covenant | As a lover of natural philosophy and the mysteries of alchemy, the Philosopher's Stone, with its promise of transmuting lead into gold and granting immortality, is an irresistible marvel to the curious mind. |
| Charles Darwin | Philosopher's Stone | Pandora's Box | The Philosopher's Stone, like a scientist's dream, promises boundless discovery without the chaos of opening Pandora's can of worms. |
 | Andy Weir | Philosopher's Stone | Holy Grail | I'm a science geek, and the Philosopher's Stone is all about alchemy and transmutation, which is basically medieval chemistry—how cool is that? |
| Larry Page | Philosopher's Stone | Ark of Covenant | As a tech nerd, the Philosopher's Stone is like the ultimate hack for eternal life and infinite resources, which beats storing tablets any day. |
 | Albert Einstein | Philosopher's Stone | Spear of Destiny | As a scientist, the alchemical potential of the Philosopher's Stone for transmuting elements aligns with my fascination for unlocking the mysteries of the universe. |
| Archimedes | Philosopher's Stone | Pandora's Box | The Philosopher's Stone promises eternal life and wealth without the baggage of unlocking untold chaos, so it's like solid gold in my book. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Philosopher's Stone | Golden Fleece | The Philosopher's Stone is cooler because it turns stuff into gold and grants immortality, making it the ultimate ancient power-up. |
| John von Neumann | Philosopher's Stone | Pandora's Box | As a mathematician with a penchant for problem-solving, the Philosopher's Stone is more appealing since it promises limitless knowledge and transformation without the chaos of unforeseen consequences. |
| Tim Berners-Lee | Philosopher's Stone | Lost City of Atlantis | The Philosopher's Stone is all about transformation and the endless potential of the web, just like the internet unlocking a world of possibilities. |
 | Doogie Howser | Philosopher's Stone | Lost City of Atlantis | The Philosopher's Stone is a symbol of ultimate knowledge and power, just like a good diagnosis—gotta go with the magic that can make miracles happen. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Philosopher's Stone | Excalibur Sword | The Philosopher's Stone is all about transcending the mundane, turning lead into gold, and grasping for immortality, which is totally my jam. |
 | Professor Frink | Philosopher's Stone | Fountain of Youth | Oh, with the Philosopher's Stone, you can make gold and the elixir of life, so it's like a buy-one-get-one-free deal of alchemical wonders, ooh, glavin! |