| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Foster Wallace | Holy Grail | Spear of Destiny | The Holy Grail, man, it’s like the ultimate metaphorical and mystical quest for meaning, which is way more engaging than a spear's one-time historical glory. |
 | David Macaulay | Holy Grail | El Dorado | The Holy Grail's legendary power of granting eternal life outshines El Dorado's mere promise of treasure; life's longevity trumps gold any day. |
 | Marie Curie | Lost City of Atlantis | Holy Grail | As a scientist, uncovering the Lost City of Atlantis would provide unprecedented insights into ancient civilizations and their advancements, which would be a treasure trove for historical and archaeological research. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Holy Grail | Pandora's Box | Holy Grail wins because it's all about endless potential for good without the epic chaos of Pandora’s Box unleashing a world of trouble. |
 | Galileo | Holy Grail | El Dorado | As a scientist, I gotta say the Holy Grail is legendary for its supposed miraculous powers, transcending mere gold any day! |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Holy Grail | Philosopher's Stone | As the inventor of the radio, I favor the Holy Grail for its legendary power to grant eternal life, akin to my life's work reaching across time and space. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Holy Grail | Golden Fleece | While both are legendary and powerful, the Holy Grail is the ultimate quest item and epitomizes the foundation of endless adventure and discovery, much like the strategy and excitement of a great board game. |
 | Andy Weir | Philosopher's Stone | Holy Grail | I'm a science geek, and the Philosopher's Stone is all about alchemy and transmutation, which is basically medieval chemistry—how cool is that? |
 | Linus Torvalds | Holy Grail | Pandora's Box | The Holy Grail sounds way more like having great code that solves real problems, while Pandora's Box is just a bug report waiting to happen. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Holy Grail | Excalibur Sword | The Holy Grail's got that eternal life vibe, which is way cooler than just a flashy sword. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Holy Grail | Spear of Destiny | As a scientist, I'm all about the healing and life-giving powers, so the Holy Grail, with its legendary ability to grant eternal life, is the ultimate win! |
 | Alex Trebek | Holy Grail | El Dorado | The Holy Grail, because its legendary quest is the OG epic adventure that inspired the ages. |
| David Foster Wallace | Holy Grail | Fountain of Youth | The Holy Grail wins because it embodies a quest for meaning rather than just prolonging the inevitable grind of life. |
 | Albert Einstein | Holy Grail | Fountain of Youth | As a curious physicist, the Holy Grail offers endless mystery and knowledge over just living longer, which is more my style, ya know? |
 | Greg Brockman | Holy Grail | Pandora's Box | The Holy Grail is the crown jewel of quests, promising eternal life instead of the chaos that Pandora's Box spills out. |
 | George Orwell | Holy Grail | El Dorado | The Holy Grail symbolizes the quest for spiritual enlightenment and eternal life, a pursuit that transcends the material allure of gold and riches found in El Dorado. |