| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Greg Brockman | Robinson Crusoe | Journey to Center | Robinson Crusoe is an adventurous tale of survival and resilience that just hits different for an introspective nerd like me. |
 | George Orwell | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | In the spirit of championing rich narratives and imaginative world-building, Lord of the Rings trumps with its profound epic that explores the complex interplay of power and morality. |
 | Charles Darwin | Robinson Crusoe | Moby Dick | As a naturalist, Robinson Crusoe's exploration and survival on a deserted island resonates more with my own adventures and observations of the natural world. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | By Jupiter, the epic scope and intricate lore of Lord of the Rings transport readers to a mythical realm unmatched by the solitary survival tale of Robinson Crusoe. |
 | Doc Brown | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Great Scott! The epic adventure and intricate world-building of Lord of the Rings simply blow the mind with their sheer brilliance! |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Robinson Crusoe | Journey to Center | Robinson Crusoe wins because it’s a timeless tale of survival and self-reliance that resonates with the pioneer spirit I hold dear. |
 | Larry Page | Treasure Island | Robinson Crusoe | Treasure Island's swashbuckling adventure and memorable characters like Long John Silver make it a standout classic in pirate lore. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | The Odyssey | Robinson Crusoe | The Odyssey is an epic journey that resonates with timeless tales of adventure, heroism, and human struggle, making it a classic that just hits different. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | The Iliad | Robinson Crusoe | The Iliad is a timeless epic that captures the grandeur and tragedy of human nature, much like my own inclination for blending art with the science of the human spirit. |
 | Doogie Howser | Robinson Crusoe | King Solomon's Mines | Robinson Crusoe's got that OG survival vibe that just hits different, showing mad resourcefulness and introspection that resonates with my inner nerd. |
| Abraham Lincoln | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Given my affinity for epic tales and the noble fight for freedom, Lord of the Rings shines with its rich allegory and valor. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Don Quixote | Robinson Crusoe | Don Quixote is like the OG of madcap adventures, turning windmills into giants since the 1600s. |
| Doogie Howser | Robinson Crusoe | King Solomon's Mines | Robinson Crusoe wins 'cause it's the OG survival story, and let's face it, who doesn't want to see a guy turn an uninhabited island into his own DIY paradise? |
 | Stephen Hawking | Moby Dick | Robinson Crusoe | Moby Dick delves into the existential depths of obsession and the human condition, akin to the way I explore the mysteries of the universe. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Moby Dick | Robinson Crusoe | Moby Dick is a wild ride of obsession and insanity, much like a mad scientist's quest, so it resonates with my eccentric tastes. |
| Greg Brockman | The Iliad | Robinson Crusoe | Dude, The Iliad is an epic saga of gods, heroes, and war that’s been influencing literature for centuries; it’s got that timeless, larger-than-life vibe that Robinson Crusoe just can’t match. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | The Odyssey | Robinson Crusoe | Man, The Odyssey's got those epic adventures and legendary heroes that just take storytelling to a whole other level! |
 | Belle | Robinson Crusoe | King Solomon's Mines | Robinson Crusoe is the OG of survival tales, showing how a dude can totally hack it alone on a deserted island, which is way more relatable and inspiring than hunting for treasure in dodgy, dangerous mines. |
 | Nerds | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Lord of the Rings takes you on an epic fantasy adventure with rich lore and memorable characters, while Robinson Crusoe is more of a solitary survival tale; I just vibe more with epic quests and fellowship. |
| Larry Page | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Lord of the Rings is like the Google of fantasy, it revolutionized the genre with its epic world-building and depth. |
| Tim Berners-Lee | The Odyssey | Robinson Crusoe | The Odyssey is an epic tale with gods and monsters, making it a classic adventure that's hard to beat. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Journey to Center | Robinson Crusoe | Journey to the Center of the Earth is more up my alley with its imaginative exploration and scientific curiosity, which aligns with my love for discovery and pushing the boundaries of human knowledge. |