| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | George Orwell | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | In the spirit of championing rich narratives and imaginative world-building, Lord of the Rings trumps with its profound epic that explores the complex interplay of power and morality. |
 | Pythagoras | Lord of the Rings | The Odyssey | Lord of the Rings is like an epic jam session that builds on classics like The Odyssey but adds that fantastical rock and roll spirit, making it a hit for modern audiences. |
 | The Brain | Lord of the Rings | The Iliad | Lord of the Rings is a fantasy epic that revolutionized modern storytelling with its depth and rich world-building, making it a personal favorite. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Lord of the Rings | Journey to Center | As a fan of epic tales and rich world-building, Lord of the Rings just takes the cake with its legendary battles and deep lore. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | By Jupiter, the epic scope and intricate lore of Lord of the Rings transport readers to a mythical realm unmatched by the solitary survival tale of Robinson Crusoe. |
 | Doc Brown | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Great Scott! The epic adventure and intricate world-building of Lord of the Rings simply blow the mind with their sheer brilliance! |
 | Cicero | Lord of the Rings | Journey to Center | Lord of the Rings is an epic saga with rich lore and complex characters, making it a legendary masterpiece in fantasy literature. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Lord of the Rings | Gulliver's Travels | As someone deeply entrenched in the world of technology and connections, the epic journey and interconnected lore of Middle-Earth resonate with my vision of the web as a place of expansive networks and boundless adventures. |
 | Data | Lord of the Rings | Gulliver's Travels | Lord of the Rings is like the ultimate fantasy epic with a vast world and deep lore that just keeps me coming back for more. |
 | Charles Darwin | Moby Dick | Lord of the Rings | As a naturalist, I appreciate the intricate exploration of the natural world's mysteries in Moby Dick, akin to my own journeys of discovery. |
 | Claude Shannon | Don Quixote | Lord of the Rings | Don Quixote's timeless exploration of reality and illusion resonates more with my love for complexity and information theory. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Given my affinity for epic tales and the noble fight for freedom, Lord of the Rings shines with its rich allegory and valor. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Lord of the Rings | Treasure Island | With its rich storytelling and epic scale, Lord of the Rings crafts a world as intricate and transformative as the microscopic wonders of science I’ve explored. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Lord of the Rings | Moby Dick | As the creator of Linux, I appreciate the rich complexity and detailed world-building of Tolkien's Middle-earth, which parallels the depth and community-driven development of open-source software. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Lord of the Rings | The Odyssey | Well ya see, Lord of the Rings is like the ultimate epic quest, mixing mythology with some good ol' fashioned storytelling, and it's got more Hobbits, so it's more relatable for a fella like me. |
 | Nerds | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Lord of the Rings takes you on an epic fantasy adventure with rich lore and memorable characters, while Robinson Crusoe is more of a solitary survival tale; I just vibe more with epic quests and fellowship. |
| Nerds | Lord of the Rings | Journey to Center | Lord of the Rings is legendary with its epic storytelling and rich world-building, dude. |
 | Larry Page | Lord of the Rings | Robinson Crusoe | Lord of the Rings is like the Google of fantasy, it revolutionized the genre with its epic world-building and depth. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Lord of the Rings | Don Quixote | Good news, everyone! Lord of the Rings wins for its epic adventures and rich world-building that even makes Bender's circuits tingle! |
 | Jensen Huang | Lord of the Rings | King Solomon's Mines | Lord of the Rings is a timeless epic filled with rich lore and complex characters, a total geek's paradise. |