| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Professor Frink | Atlantis | Anasazi | Oh, glavin! Atlantis gets the edge because of its super-advanced technology and the mystery of it being this legendary underwater city, which is like a scientific playground for nerds, ya know, with all the potential gizmos and doodads to explore! |
 | Pythagoras | Minoans | Atlantis | Yo, the Minoans were legit with their real-deal civilization vibes, while Atlantis is all myth and mystery, fam. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Göbekli Tepe | Atlantis | Göbekli Tepe is the real deal with actual archaeological evidence, while Atlantis is more legend than reality. |
 | Data | Rapa Nui | Atlantis | Rapa Nui is the real deal with its epic stone heads, while Atlantis is just a mythical 'what if' story. |
 | Grace Hopper | Indus Valley | Atlantis | Indus Valley is the real deal with actual artifacts and history, whereas Atlantis is more of a legendary tale. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Harappan society | Atlantis | Harappan society wins for its archaeological evidence and historical impact, while Atlantis remains a captivating myth. |
| Grace Hopper | Göbekli Tepe | Atlantis | Göbekli Tepe is the real deal, an archaeological site that rewrote history, while Atlantis is still just a legend swimming around in our imaginations. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Harappan society | Atlantis | Harappan society actually existed and had advanced urban planning, while Atlantis is just a legendary tale. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Etruscans | Atlantis | Etruscans were real and influential in shaping early Roman culture, while Atlantis is just a legendary city—cool story but not historically impactful. |
 | Alex Trebek | Rapa Nui | Atlantis | Rapa Nui, or Easter Island, is real and has those awesome giant stone heads, while Atlantis is just a lost city legend. |
 | Archimedes | Etruscans | Atlantis | The Etruscans were real and left behind a rich cultural legacy, while Atlantis is just a legendary tale. |
| Lonnie Johnson | Rapa Nui | Atlantis | Rapa Nui's real moai statues are way cooler to explore than a legendary city that might not even exist, you know? |
 | Charles Darwin | Rapa Nui | Atlantis | While Atlantis is a legendary place shrouded in myth with no observable evidence, Rapa Nui, or Easter Island, offers real-world insights into human ingenuity and the consequences of environmental overuse with its iconic Moai statues. |
| Neal Stephenson | Indus Valley | Atlantis | The Indus Valley Civilization was a real and historically documented society known for its advanced urban planning, while Atlantis is a legendary city with no scientific evidence of its existence. |
| Grace Hopper | Minoans | Atlantis | The Minoans were real, and they left behind some pretty rad archaeological evidence that shows they were advanced for their time. |
 | Nerds | Indus Valley | Atlantis | Dude, the Indus Valley was real, left some rad ancient tech, and had legit city planning vibes—Atlantis is just a myth, man! |
| Grace Hopper | Göbekli Tepe | Atlantis | Göbekli Tepe is the real deal in ancient history, as it’s a tangible site that reshaped our understanding of early civilization, while Atlantis is more mythical and speculative. |
 | Andy Weir | Etruscans | Atlantis | The Etruscans were a real civilization with a significant influence on Rome, whereas Atlantis is a fictional story that doesn't have historical merit. |
 | The Brain | Indus Valley | Atlantis | Indus Valley was real, dude, with cities and plumbing; Atlantis is just an epic myth. |