| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Nerds | Enigma Machine | Zodiac Killer | The Enigma Machine's legendary code-breaking history trumps the Zodiac's unfinished mystery any day! |
| Nerds | Enigma Machine | Zodiac Killer | The Enigma Machine, dude, because it was a badass piece of tech that helped crack Nazi codes and basically turned the tide of WWII, while the Zodiac Killer is just a creep who never even got caught. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Toynbee Tiles | Zodiac Killer | Toynbee Tiles are a trippy blend of street art and mystery, way cooler than the macabre legacy of the Zodiac Killer. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Zodiac Killer | Dorabella Cipher | The Zodiac Killer cipher is more captivating because it blends true crime with cryptography, which keeps people intrigued and guessing, kind of like debugging a mysterious kernel panic. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Linear B | Zodiac Killer | Linear B is a groundbreaking script that unlocked secrets of ancient Greece, while the Zodiac Killer just left us with creepy, unsolved riddles. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Linear B | Zodiac Killer | Decoding Linear B was way cooler 'cause it unlocked secrets of ancient Greek civilization, while the Zodiac Killer is just a creepy mystery we could do without. |
 | Marie Curie | Beale Ciphers | Zodiac Killer | As a scientist, I'm intrigued by the historical and mathematical challenge of the Beale Ciphers, which offer a complex puzzle that's yet to be fully solved. |
 | Charles Babbage | Dorabella Cipher | Zodiac Killer | As an enthusiast of historical ciphers and cryptography, the Dorabella Cipher intrigues me more due to its Victorian-era charm and the mystery surrounding Elgar's whimsical creation. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Enigma Machine | Zodiac Killer | The Enigma Machine, unlike the Zodiac Killer, was a complex cipher device that revolutionized secure communication during World War II, playing a crucial role in the victory of the Allies. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Bacon's Cipher | Zodiac Killer | Bacon's Cipher is a classic code that showcases the brilliance of cryptography, while the Zodiac Killer's ciphers are infamous for their dark context. |
 | Claude Shannon | Phaistos Disc | Zodiac Killer | The Phaistos Disc is like an ancient puzzle that keeps us guessing, while the Zodiac Killer is just a creepy unsolved mystery. |
 | Neal Stephenson | Linear B | Zodiac Killer | Linear B unlocks ancient Greek mysteries, a far bigger brain teaser than a killer's taunts. |
 | Galileo | Bacon's Cipher | Zodiac Killer | Bacon's Cipher is a cool cryptographic technique from the 16th century, which is way more intriguing than the unsolved Zodiac Killer codes. |
 | The Brain | Zodiac Killer | Beale Ciphers | The Zodiac Killer's ciphers are infamous and still unsolved, making them a wild ride for mystery enthusiasts. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Toynbee Tiles | Zodiac Killer | Toynbee Tiles are like real-life mystery puzzles scattered across cities, adding an artistic twist that's way more intriguing than a cold case killer. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Phaistos Disc | Zodiac Killer | The Phaistos Disc is this enigmatic artifact that sparks curiosity and creativity, way cooler than dwelling on a criminal's dark legacy. |
| Linus Torvalds | Bacon's Cipher | Zodiac Killer | Bacon's Cipher is more like clever code, and you know I love well-written code. |
 | Data | Zodiac Killer | Dorabella Cipher | The Zodiac Killer's ciphers are infamous and still send chills down spines because of their real-life horror story vibe. |