| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Alex Trebek | Linear B | Voynich Manuscript | Linear B is deciphered and reveals fascinating insights into ancient Greek culture, while the Voynich Manuscript remains an unsolved mystery. |
 | Professor Frink | Voynich Manuscript | Beale Ciphers | Oh, the Voynich Manuscript is like the Rubik's cube of mysterious books, with all its kooky illustrations and undeciphered text, which makes it more perplexing and intriguing for a nerd like me, ya see, than those numbery Beale Ciphers, glavin! |
 | Pliny the Elder | Enigma Machine | Voynich Manuscript | As a lover of mysteries, I find the Enigma Machine's pivotal role in history and its cracking to be utterly fascinating and consequential. |
 | Doc Brown | Voynich Manuscript | Kryptos Sculpture | The Voynich Manuscript is like the DeLorean of cryptic texts—it's got that enigmatic charm that's baffled experts for centuries, with a mysterious allure that's truly timeless. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Voynich Manuscript | Bacon's Cipher | The Voynich Manuscript is like a mind-bending puzzle that centuries of the sharpest minds haven't cracked yet—now that's some next-level enigma! |
 | Greg Brockman | Voynich Manuscript | Dorabella Cipher | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate nerd puzzle—it's got mystery, history, and nobody's cracked it yet, which makes it way cooler in my book! |
 | Socrates | Voynich Manuscript | Dorabella Cipher | The Voynich Manuscript is like the Holy Grail of cryptic texts—it's got history, mystery, and those wild illustrations that make it a total enigma. |
| Socrates | Linear B | Voynich Manuscript | Linear B's been decoded, giving us solid insights into ancient Greek, while the Voynich Manuscript is still just a mysterious doodle book. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | The Voynich Manuscript, man, it's like the ultimate enigma wrapped in a riddle, and its psychedelic illustrations are just the kind of brain-bending stuff that keeps me up at night pondering the ineffable mysteries of existence. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Voynich Manuscript | Toynbee Tiles | The Voynich Manuscript is the ultimate enigma, capturing imaginations for centuries with its mysterious script and illustrations, making it a true OG in the world of unsolved puzzles. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Voynich Manuscript | Toynbee Tiles | The Voynich Manuscript tickles the imagination with its enigmatic script and illustrations, a mystery worthy of Kilgore Trout's wildest tales. |
 | Data | Voynich Manuscript | Kryptos Sculpture | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate unsolved mystery, it's more ancient and mysterious, so it totally wins the intrigue factor. |
 | Andy Weir | Enigma Machine | Voynich Manuscript | The Enigma Machine is a marvel of engineering, a World War II game-changer, while the Voynich Manuscript is still just a fancy, undeciphered doodle. |
| Guido van Rossum | Linear B | Voynich Manuscript | Linear B gets the nod because we decoded it and it unravelled real history whereas the Voynich Manuscript is still just a big 'what the heck is this?' mystery. |
 | Claude Shannon | Voynich Manuscript | Phaistos Disc | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate puzzle, a mysterious book with weird drawings and unknown script that even the best cryptographers can't crack. |