| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Toynbee Tiles | Zodiac Killer | Toynbee Tiles are a trippy blend of street art and mystery, way cooler than the macabre legacy of the Zodiac Killer. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Enigma Machine | Toynbee Tiles | As a scientist who deeply values innovation and technological impact, the Enigma Machine's role in cryptography and its influence on history makes it the clear standout. |
 | Marie Curie | Enigma Machine | Toynbee Tiles | The Enigma Machine is a monumental breakthrough in cryptography, instrumental in cracking codes during WWII, while Toynbee Tiles are mysterious and intriguing but don't match the Enigma's historical impact. |
 | Andy Weir | Enigma Machine | Toynbee Tiles | As a science and tech nerd, the Enigma Machine is a fascinating piece of cryptographic history that was pivotal in WWII, unlike the quirky mystery of Toynbee Tiles. |
 | Charles Darwin | Linear B | Toynbee Tiles | Linear B is like the OG script that unlocked the secrets of ancient Greek life, while Toynbee Tiles are more of a modern mystery vibe. |
 | Copernicus | Bacon's Cipher | Toynbee Tiles | Bacon's Cipher is the ultimate mashup of history and cryptography, offering a cool way to hide messages that beats the mysterious vibes of Toynbee Tiles any day. |
 | Socrates | Beale Ciphers | Toynbee Tiles | Beale Ciphers are like the ultimate cryptographic mystery, a treasure hunt with brains, while Toynbee Tiles are cool and all, they're more like street art with a twist. |
 | Nerds | Linear B | Toynbee Tiles | Linear B's the OG script that unlocked the mysteries of Mycenaean Greece, while Toynbee Tiles are cool but more like street art easter eggs. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Dorabella Cipher | Toynbee Tiles | Good news, everyone! The Dorabella Cipher tickles my cryptographic curiosity more than Toynbee Tiles because who doesn’t love a good old-fashioned unsolved puzzle? |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Voynich Manuscript | Toynbee Tiles | The Voynich Manuscript is the ultimate enigma, capturing imaginations for centuries with its mysterious script and illustrations, making it a true OG in the world of unsolved puzzles. |
 | Cicero | Phaistos Disc | Toynbee Tiles | The Phaistos Disc is like the OG mysterious artifact, a real ancient puzzle that hasn't been cracked yet! |
 | George Washington Carver | Kryptos Sculpture | Toynbee Tiles | Kryptos Sculpture's got that cryptic edge and a dash of mystery that pulls you in like a puzzle you can't put down. |
 | Alex Trebek | Toynbee Tiles | Linear B | While Linear B is a treasure of ancient linguistics, Toynbee Tiles are a modern urban mystery that just hits differently with their enigmatic, street-art vibes. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Voynich Manuscript | Toynbee Tiles | The Voynich Manuscript tickles the imagination with its enigmatic script and illustrations, a mystery worthy of Kilgore Trout's wildest tales. |
 | Professor Frink | Enigma Machine | Toynbee Tiles | Oh, good glavin, the Enigma Machine was a pivotal cryptographic device that impacted World War II, while the Toynbee Tiles are an enigmatic art mystery, but decoding wartime messages is a bit more important, I would say, mm-hm! |
 | Richard P Feynman | Beale Ciphers | Toynbee Tiles | The Beale Ciphers are like a nerd's treasure hunt with layers of mystery and unsolved codes, which is just irresistible to a curious mind. |
| Louis Pasteur | Bacon's Cipher | Toynbee Tiles | As a scientist, I appreciate Bacon's Cipher for its intellectual intrigue and historical significance in the world of cryptography more than the mysterious street art of Toynbee Tiles. |
| Charles Darwin | Linear B | Toynbee Tiles | Linear B is like the OG script that cracked open the mysteries of ancient Greece, while Toynbee Tiles are just some funky street art with a cult following. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Toynbee Tiles | Zodiac Killer | Toynbee Tiles are like real-life mystery puzzles scattered across cities, adding an artistic twist that's way more intriguing than a cold case killer. |
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Beale Ciphers | Toynbee Tiles | As the creator of the World Wide Web, I'm all about decoding hidden messages in data, so Beale Ciphers win this round! |
 | Doogie Howser | Toynbee Tiles | Bacon's Cipher | Toynbee Tiles are like the mysterious street art version of Easter eggs in life, just cooler and more enigmatic than a cryptic cipher. |
| Kurt Vonnegut | Toynbee Tiles | Linear B | Toynbee Tiles are like a mysterious, urban art project that makes you question reality, which is way cooler than deciphering old scripts, man. |