| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Klaus Teuber | Voynich Manuscript | Kensington Runestone | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate mystery, just like a game of Catan, where every page feels like a new terrain to explore and decode. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Kensington Runestone | Dropa Stones | The Kensington Runestone is a fascinating piece of Americana, stirring up local legends and a sense of exploration, while the Dropa Stones, despite their allure, remain shrouded in more speculative mystery. |
 | Data | Antikythera Mechanism | Kensington Runestone | The Antikythera Mechanism is like an ancient Greek computer, showcasing mind-blowing engineering way ahead of its time, while the Kensington Runestone's authenticity is still debated. |
 | David Macaulay | Sacsayhuamán Walls | Kensington Runestone | Sacsayhuamán Walls are like this epic, mind-blowing feat of ancient engineering that just leaves you in awe of how those massive stones came together without modern tech. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Rongorongo Tablets | Kensington Runestone | As a scientist who loves cracking the mysteries of the past, the Rongorongo Tablets are like a linguistic puzzle waiting to be solved, while the Kensington Runestone just seems like a cool story. |
| Louis Pasteur | Voynich Manuscript | Kensington Runestone | The Voynich Manuscript is like the ultimate puzzle game for nerds, with mysterious illustrations and undeciphered text that make it a more intriguing enigma than the Kensington Runestone. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Voynich Manuscript | Kensington Runestone | The Voynich Manuscript is shrouded in mystery with its undeciphered script, making it the ultimate puzzle for curious minds like mine. |
| Data | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc's mysterious symbols and undeciphered script make it the ultimate enigma in archaeology, capturing the imagination like no other artifact. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | The Phaistos Disc is like the ultimate ancient mystery, with its undeciphered script keeping everyone guessing, just like a puzzle wrapped in an enigma! |
 | Greg Brockman | Rongorongo Tablets | Kensington Runestone | Rongorongo Tablets are like the ultimate unsolved puzzle, making them way cooler for those who dig a good mystery. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Phaistos Disc | Kensington Runestone | As a man of science and mystery, the enigmatic and undeciphered Phaistos Disc holds the charm of an unresolved puzzle, evoking the allure of ancient innovation. |
 | Archimedes | Kensington Runestone | Dropa Stones | The Kensington Runestone's got that Viking explorer vibe, making it a more solid historical enigma compared to the dubious extraterrestrial claims tied to the Dropa Stones. |
 | Albert Einstein | Sacsayhuamán Walls | Kensington Runestone | Sacsayhuamán Walls are a marvel of ancient engineering with their massive stones perfectly fitted without mortar, while the Kensington Runestone's authenticity is still debated. |
| David Foster Wallace | Stone Spheres | Kensington Runestone | The Stone Spheres are just way more enigmatic and cool, like something out of a dream where geometry and mystery have a sweet little dance. |
 | Professor Frink | Kensington Runestone | Dropa Stones | Oh, glayvin! The Kensington Runestone, with its runic inscriptions, is a fascinating piece of Minnesotan history that's stirred up scholarly debate for over a century, whereas the Dropa Stones' origin story is more like a sci-fi adventure with less, uh, credible backing. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Voynich Manuscript | Kensington Runestone | As a scientist and lover of cryptography, the Voynich Manuscript offers a unique and unsolved mystery of language and encryption that continues to intrigue and challenge the brightest minds. |
 | Claude Shannon | Kensington Runestone | Dropa Stones | The Kensington Runestone is more intriguing because it's got that Minnesota mystery vibe and sparks debates among historians about Vikings in America. |
| Data | Sacsayhuamán Walls | Kensington Runestone | Sacsayhuamán Walls are just mind-blowingly epic in scale and craftsmanship, while the Kensington Runestone is still under debate. |
 | Stephen Hawking | Antikythera Mechanism | Kensington Runestone | The Antikythera Mechanism is a mind-blowing ancient computer, showing advanced astronomical understanding, while the Kensington Runestone's authentic origin is still debated; the Mechanism's complexity is just unparalleled. |