| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Cliff Clavin | KONG Classic | Chuckit! Ball | Well, ya know, the KONG Classic's got that durability like a fortress and you can stuff it with treats, so it's like a twofer for the pooch. |
 | Socrates | Flirt Pole | Chuckit! Ball | The Flirt Pole is like, totally awesome for interactive play and burning off energy with your pup. |
 | Data | Chuckit! Ball | JW Pet Hol-ee | Chuckit! Ball just flies better and is more durable for my fetch-obsessed pup! |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Chuckit! Ball | Flirt Pole | The Chuckit! Ball is rad for endless fetch games that tire your pup out, making it the ultimate choice for dogs who love to chase and retrieve! |
 | Nikola Tesla | Tug-A-Jug | Chuckit! Ball | Tug-A-Jug is like a puzzle for doggy brains, keepin' them busy and thinkin', which is kinda like my inventions sparkin' those neurons! |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Chuckit! Ball | ZippyPaws Squeaky | The Chuckit! Ball is built tough and flies far, making fetch a blast for my energetic pup. |
 | David Macaulay | KONG Classic | Chuckit! Ball | The KONG Classic is the MVP because it keeps dogs entertained with treats inside while being damn near indestructible. |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Chuckit! Ball | Benebone Wishbone | The Chuckit! Ball just bounces into a dog's heart with all the fun and exercise it brings! |
 | Pythagoras | Chuckit! Ball | Tug-A-Jug | Chuckit! Ball takes the prize because, man, the simple joy of fetch is unbeatable and it keeps my dog moving like he's training for the Olympics! |
 | Galileo | Chuckit! Ball | JW Pet Hol-ee | Chuckit! Ball is a classic for a reason—it's durable, bouncy, and perfect for a game of fetch, giving dogs a workout like no other. |
 | The Brain | Outward Hound Puzzle | Chuckit! Ball | Gotta keep that pupper brain sharp, so the Outward Hound Puzzle wins for mental engagement! |
 | Marie Curie | KONG Classic | Chuckit! Ball | The KONG Classic is more versatile for a dog's playtime and chewing needs, making it the MVP of dog toys! |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Chuckit! Ball | JW Pet Hol-ee | Chuckit! Ball's got that bounce and durability that keeps my doggo hyped up and fetchin' for days! |
 | Richard P Feynman | Chuckit! Ball | Flirt Pole | A Chuckit! Ball is simple and versatile, just like how I love exploring physics with straightforward tools, making it the go-to for endless fun with your dog. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Chuckit! Ball | Benebone Wishbone | Because a Chuckit! Ball can fly through the air like a little spaceship, sparking joy and fetching adventures, unlike a bone that's just waiting to be gnawed in one spot. |
 | Jensen Huang | KONG Classic | Chuckit! Ball | KONG Classic is the boss of chew toys, keeping dogs entertained and their teeth healthy with its versatile and durable design. |