| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Pythagoras | Reptilian Elite | Flat Earth Theory | Both theories are wildly speculative, but at least the Reptilian Elite gives you a sci-fi thriller vibe, whereas Flat Earth is just dismissing basic geometry. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | HAARP Weather Control | Flat Earth Theory | HAARP Weather Control's got more sciencey-sounding stuff behind it, even if it's all hogwash, so it scores higher in the conspiracy ring. |
 | Andy Weir | Big Pharma Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | Big Pharma Secrets wins because at least they're based on real entities and money, whereas Flat Earth Theory is just ignoring basic physics and common sense. |
 | Cicero | Chemtrail Cover-up | Flat Earth Theory | Considering the evidence, chemtrails have more folks buying into the conspiracy than the flat Earth theory, which is kinda out there. |
 | Claude Shannon | HAARP Weather Control | Flat Earth Theory | HAARP Weather Control is more believable because at least it builds on some real science, even if it's wildly exaggerated. |
 | Louis Pasteur | JFK Assassination | Flat Earth Theory | As a scientist who values evidence, the overwhelming lack of scientific support makes Flat Earth Theory far less credible than the well-documented and widely investigated JFK Assassination. |
 | Doc Brown | Moon Landing Hoax | Flat Earth Theory | Great Scott! The Moon Landing Hoax has some folks scratching their heads with plausible technology doubts, while Flat Earth is like arguing the DeLorean runs on steam! |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Big Pharma Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | Big Pharma Secrets have the edge because, unlike Flat Earth Theory, they're rooted in the real-world intrigue of corporate shenanigans. |
 | Albert Einstein | HAARP Weather Control | Flat Earth Theory | Ain't no way the Earth is flat when I've seen the curvature my own darn self, but HAARP's got some science behind it, even if it's twisted. |
 | Albert Einstein | Big Pharma Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | Big Pharma Secrets, because while the flat earth idea is as cooked as a noodle in boiling water, the pharmaceutical industry's shenanigans at least have some threads of truth worth a deeper look. |
 | Socrates | Moon Landing Hoax | Flat Earth Theory | The Moon Landing Hoax at least spins around a real event, whereas Flat Earth Theory just ignores basic geography. |
 | Grace Hopper | JFK Assassination | Flat Earth Theory | JFK Assassination theories got layers and intrigue, while Flat Earth is just ignoring evidence and science. |
 | Cliff Clavin | New World Order | Flat Earth Theory | Well ya know, the New World Order's got more legs to stand on, what with all the political intrigue and shadowy cabals, unlike that flat Earth nonsense which is flatter than a pancake. |
 | John von Neumann | New World Order | Flat Earth Theory | The New World Order theory, while still speculative, involves complex geopolitical elements that are more grounded in reality than the scientifically debunked Flat Earth Theory. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Big Pharma Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | As someone who champions science, I find Big Pharma Secrets more plausible, as the Flat Earth theory contradicts fundamental physics and observable evidence. |
 | Doc Brown | Big Pharma Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | Great Scott! Big Pharma Secrets is the winner because it's got more intrigue and real-world shenanigans compared to the flat-out bonkers Flat Earth Theory. |
 | Greg Brockman | Area 51 Secrets | Flat Earth Theory | Area 51 Secrets are more intriguing because they involve mysterious government stuff and potential alien tech, which is way cooler than a debunked theory. |
 | David Macaulay | HAARP Weather Control | Flat Earth Theory | Dude, HAARP's got that mad scientist vibe, while Flat Earth is just like, what even? |
 | Socrates | HAARP Weather Control | Flat Earth Theory | HAARP Weather Control is the winner 'cause at least it’s based on a real research facility and not just a medieval misunderstanding of the planet. |
 | Nikola Tesla | New World Order | Flat Earth Theory | New World Order has more grounding in historical and geopolitical contexts, while Flat Earth Theory defies basic scientific understanding. |
 | George Washington Carver | Reptilian Elite | Flat Earth Theory | Ain't no way lizards in human suits pullin' strings tops a pancake planet story. |