| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Antoine Lavoisier | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | JFK Assassination's intrigue and mystery have kept conspiracy theorists buzzing for decades, making it the OG of modern conspiracy debates. |
 | David Macaulay | 9/11 Inside Job | Reptilian Elite | 9/11 Inside Job is more grounded in political and historical events, making it a more plausible conspiracy theory compared to the far-fetched idea of a Reptilian Elite controlling the world. |
 | John von Neumann | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | The JFK Assassination is a classic mystery with layers of intrigue and conspiracy theories that continue to captivate historians and the public alike. |
 | Cicero | 9/11 Inside Job | Chemtrail Cover-up | 9/11 Inside Job's got more layers and twists, making it the drama king of conspiracy theories. |
 | The Brain | Area 51 Secrets | 9/11 Inside Job | Aliens and secret tech at Area 51 are just way cooler to speculate about than 9/11 conspiracies which are a bit too dark and serious for some folks. |
| Cicero | 9/11 Inside Job | Reptilian Elite | 9/11 Inside Job is classic conspiracy lore with more tangible hooks to real-world events, making it a juicier rabbit hole to dive into compared to the more outlandish Reptilian Elite theory. |
 | Albert Einstein | Moon Landing Hoax | 9/11 Inside Job | As a physicist, the physics involved in landing on the moon checks out, while the complexities of conspiracy theories around 9/11 have too many unverifiable layers. |
 | Socrates | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | The mystery and endless debates about JFK's assassination, with its conspiracy theories and cultural impact, still capture the imagination more than the complex and painful narrative of 9/11 being an inside job. |
 | Stephen Hawking | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | The JFK Assassination is more compelling because it combines historical intrigue and mystery with a labyrinth of conspiracy theories that have fascinated generations. |
 | Claude Shannon | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | JFK Assassination is classic conspiracy gold, with layers of intrigue and mystery that have kept people speculating for decades, while 9/11 Inside Job is just too emotionally charged and recent to top the intrigue factor. |
| Albert Einstein | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | The JFK Assassination has fascinated people for decades with its layers of mystery and conspiracy, making it a more intriguing historical puzzle to solve. |
 | Neal Stephenson | 9/11 Inside Job | Moon Landing Hoax | Given the complexity and scale of 9/11 as an event, it provides a richer and grittier tapestry for conspiracy theorists to weave their intricate and speculative narratives. |
| Cicero | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | JFK Assassination has been the OG conspiracy theory since '63, making it a classic icon in the world of intrigue and speculation. |
 | Larry Page | JFK Assassination | 9/11 Inside Job | JFK Assassination is like the OG conspiracy theory, sparking endless intrigue and research, while 9/11 Inside Job is still too fresh and sensitive for many to comfortably dive into. |
 | Jensen Huang | 9/11 Inside Job | Reptilian Elite | 9/11 Inside Job has more traction in conspiracy circles because it ties into real events and government distrust, unlike the far-fetched Reptilian Elite idea. |