| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Macaulay | Abbey Road | Dark Side | Abbey Road is the ultimate blend of creative genius and musical innovation that truly defines an era, like a complex machine exhibiting flawless design and execution! |
 | Albert Einstein | Abbey Road | Exile Main St. | Abbey Road is like the grandmaster of albums, blending innovation and timeless vibes that even a theoretical physicist can groove to. |
| David Macaulay | Abbey Road | Pet Sounds | Abbey Road's seamless blend of rock genius and innovative production hits the spot every time, like an architectural masterpiece for the ears. |
 | Professor Frink | Abbey Road | Sgt. Pepper's | Oh, glayvin! Abbey Road gets the edge for its seamless medley on the second side, which, much like an endorphin-driven lab experiment, leaves listeners in a state of euphoric musical synthesis! |
 | Greg Brockman | Abbey Road | Pet Sounds | Abbey Road's blend of innovation and timeless melodies just hits different, man. |
 | The Brain | Dark Side | Abbey Road | Dark Side of the Moon is like a cosmic voyage with timeless themes and sonic innovation that's just out of this world, man. |
 | Galileo | Pet Sounds | Abbey Road | Pet Sounds changed the game with its lush arrangements and emotional depth, setting a new standard for what pop music could be. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Highway 61 | Abbey Road | Highway 61 Revisited is like a time-traveling rocket ship, blasting through the folk-rock cosmos with Dylan's lyrical genius—good news, everyone! |
 | Charles Babbage | London Calling | Abbey Road | London Calling takes the cake for its raw energy and socio-political edge that just slaps different. |
| Galileo | Abbey Road | Exile Main St. | Dude, Abbey Road is like the OG masterpiece with iconic tracks that revolutionized music man, it's a timeless classic! |
 | Cliff Clavin | Abbey Road | Pet Sounds | Well, ya see, Abbey Road's got that classic Beatles charm and the kind of musical innovation that just hits ya like a cold one at Cheers. |
 | John von Neumann | Abbey Road | London Calling | Abbey Road is a pure classic with its innovative production and iconic tracks that defined an era, man. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Abbey Road | Pet Sounds | Abbey Road's innovative studio techniques and timeless melodies resonate with my love for groundbreaking technology and perfection in design. |
 | George Washington Carver | Sgt. Pepper's | Abbey Road | Sgt. Pepper's is like the innovative peanut of music, cracking open new creative possibilities just like my favorite legume did for agriculture. |
 | Jensen Huang | London Calling | Abbey Road | London Calling rocks harder and captures the rebellious spirit that just speaks to me, especially when I'm pushing the boundaries of tech. |
| Galileo | Abbey Road | London Calling | Abbey Road is the Beatles at their absolute peak, blending innovative production with timeless songs that just hit differently. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Abbey Road | Led Zeppelin IV | Abbey Road's iconic blend of melodies and innovation makes it an absolute masterpiece, man! |
 | Archimedes | Abbey Road | Led Zeppelin IV | Abbey Road's got that smooth blend of genius and groove that just hits the sweet spot like no other. |
| Archimedes | Abbey Road | Exile Main St. | Abbey Road is like the grand finale of The Beatles' legendary run, mixing innovation and classic tunes in a way that's just pure magic. |
 | Alex Trebek | London Calling | Abbey Road | London Calling is pure punk rock energy, capturing the spirit of rebellion and change, mate! |
 | Larry Page | Abbey Road | The Beatles | Abbey Road is like the tech breakthrough of albums, smooth and polished, showcasing The Beatles at their innovative peak. |
 | Doogie Howser | Abbey Road | Dark Side | Abbey Road's blend of innovation and timeless melodies just hits differently, like a musical magnum opus that keeps on giving. |