| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Macaulay | Alien Signal Detected | Mars Colony Disaster | Alien Signal Detected is a game-changer with its cosmic intrigue and boundless potential for storytelling, making it the clear winner for someone with a passion for exploration and the unknown. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Mars Colony Disaster | Bermuda Triangle Mystery | As a scientist with an eye for the extraordinary, Mars Colony Disaster wins for its cosmic scale and potential for groundbreaking discoveries beyond this blue marble we call home. |
 | Charles Babbage | Titanic's Hidden Truth | Mars Colony Disaster | Titanic's Hidden Truth dives deep into historical intrigue, and as a history buff, I'm all in for unraveling mysteries of the past! |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Mars Colony Disaster | Elvis Presley Alive | As the inventor of the Super Soaker, I'm all about taking risks and shooting for the stars, so the thrill of a Mars Colony Disaster hits closer to my spirit of adventure. |
 | Professor Frink | Mars Colony Disaster | Titanic's Hidden Truth | Oh, glayvin, Mars Colony Disaster takes the cake with its futuristic setting and interplanetary intrigue, which, hoo, appeals to my scientific sensibilities more than historical nautical mysteries! |
 | Andy Weir | Mars Colony Disaster | Lost City Found | Mars Colony Disaster has that awesome mix of science and survival that keeps you on the edge of your seat, which is totally my jam! |
| David Macaulay | Mars Colony Disaster | Elvis Presley Alive | Mars Colony Disaster is like a sci-fi thriller that gets your brain ticking with its futuristic chaos, while Elvis being alive sounds like a trip to a conspiracy theory zone. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Bermuda Triangle Mystery | Mars Colony Disaster | Mysteries like the Bermuda Triangle fuel curiosity and imagination, making them endlessly intriguing and much more fun to explore than potential disasters. |
 | Archimedes | Haunted Mansion Secrets | Mars Colony Disaster | A haunted mansion with its eerie secrets just has more spine-tingling intrigue than a potential Mars mishap, don't you think? |
 | Jensen Huang | Mars Colony Disaster | Lost City Found | Mars Colony Disaster's sci-fi thrills and high stakes make it a captivating choice for any fan of futuristic adventures. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Elvis Presley Alive | Mars Colony Disaster | Well, ya know, Norm, Elvis being alive is like the ultimate trivia jackpot, and beats any space calamity hands down for sheer entertainment and conversation material. |
 | Charles Darwin | Haunted Mansion Secrets | Mars Colony Disaster | Blimey, Haunted Mansion Secrets tickles me curiosity with its ghostly mysteries more than a debacle on the Red Planet! |
 | Albert Einstein | Amelia Earhart Found | Mars Colony Disaster | Solving the mystery of Amelia Earhart is like finally finishing a complex puzzle that's confounded us for decades, and it gives us closure rather than crisis. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Lost City Found | Mars Colony Disaster | Lost City Found wins because the thrill of discovering ancient secrets trumps a predictable space mishap any day! |
| Professor Frink | Alien Signal Detected | Mars Colony Disaster | Oh, glavin! Detecting an alien signal means we're not alone, and that's more exciting than a Mars whoopsie! |
 | Carl Sagan | Mars Colony Disaster | Lost City Found | Mars Colony Disaster, man, it's a cosmic thrill ride with science vibes and way more planetary intrigue! |
 | Cicero | Ancient Scrolls Decoded | Mars Colony Disaster | Ancient Scrolls Decoded totally rocks because it's all about unraveling those mysterious old secrets, which is way more my jam than space mishaps. |
 | George Orwell | Mars Colony Disaster | Mona Lisa Heist | As an advocate for exploring the human condition, a Mars Colony Disaster probes deeper into society's vulnerabilities and potential for resilience. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Ancient Scrolls Decoded | Mars Colony Disaster | Ancient Scrolls Decoded wins because unraveling old mysteries is way cooler than dealing with a hypothetical Martian mess. |