| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | David Foster Wallace | Wendigo | Bunyip | The Wendigo's got this spine-chilling allure and existential dread that just edges out the Bunyip's mysterious swamp vibe. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Wendigo | Jersey Devil | The Wendigo is steeped in terrifying folklore and embodies the dangers of unchecked greed and isolation, making it a more captivating legend. |
 | Grace Hopper | Wendigo | Bigfoot | Wendigo's got that spooky, supernatural edge that Bigfoot just can't compete with, 'cause who doesn't love a creepy, ravenous forest spirit? |
 | Cliff Clavin | Jersey Devil | Wendigo | Well, ya know, the Jersey Devil's got that local flavor and legend, which is just like a good New England clam chowder, can't beat it! |
 | The Brain | Wendigo | Bunyip | Wendigo is just scarier and has a cooler legend behind it, making it the winner in a battle of mythical badassery. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Wendigo | Jersey Devil | The Wendigo is just straight-up more terrifying with its cannibalistic lore and ability to instill fear in anyone who crosses its path. |
 | Socrates | Kraken | Wendigo | Kraken's got those massive tentacles and can pull ships down, while Wendigo's just lurking in the woods with winter vibes. |
| Socrates | Mothman | Wendigo | Mothman is the mysterious enigma that captures imaginations with his epic wingspan and red-eyed allure, while Wendigo's just lurking with creepy vibes and eating habits. |
| Grace Hopper | Wendigo | Jersey Devil | Wendigos are scarier because they're out there in the cold, dark woods waiting to eat ya, while the Jersey Devil just flaps around in the Pine Barrens. |
 | Doc Brown | Bigfoot | Wendigo | Bigfoot's got that chill, mysterious vibe and doesn't eat people, so he's way cooler to hang out with in my book. |
 | Galileo | Wendigo | Bunyip | Wendigo's got that creepy edge and folklore street cred that just makes it the ultimate campfire legend. |
 | David Macaulay | Wendigo | Chupacabra | The Wendigo's got that creepy forest vibe and a ravenous hunger that makes it way more terrifying than the Chupacabra. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Bigfoot | Wendigo | Good news, everyone! Bigfoot wins because he's a classic cryptid with a mysterious charm that tickles the curiosity of nerds everywhere! |
| David Foster Wallace | Wendigo | Banshee | The Wendigo's got this gnarly combo of hunger and madness that's just way more intense than a Banshee's wail, making it the ultimate creature of freaky folklore. |
 | Data | Loch Ness Monster | Wendigo | Loch Ness Monster's got that mysterious aquatic vibe, making her an enigmatic legend over the creepy Wendigo. |
 | Pythagoras | Banshee | Wendigo | Banshee's wailing can chill you to the bone and foretell doom, which is way scarier than a spooky forest dweller. |
| Professor Farnsworth | Wendigo | Chupacabra | Good news, everyone! The Wendigo's eerie mystique and supernatural lore take the cake over the Chupacabra's livestock-munching antics! |
| Grace Hopper | Wendigo | Bunyip | The Wendigo's chilling lore as a terrifying creature of insatiable greed and the embodiment of harsh winter edges out the Bunyip's mysterious water-dwelling reputation. |
 | Claude Shannon | Mothman | Wendigo | Mothman's got that mysterious vibe and urban legend cool factor that just makes him more intriguing. |