| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Socrates | Enceladus Ocean | Archaea Extremophiles | Dude, an ocean on a moon that's spewing out water and might have alien life? That's next-level awesome! |
 | Andy Weir | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | Enceladus' ocean is like a cosmic smoothie of potential life ingredients, way more tangible than phosphine's elusive stank on Venus. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | As a geek, the mystery of an ocean under an icy shell on Enceladus is way cooler and more intriguing than some potential gas on Venus. |
 | The Brain | TRAPPIST-1 System | Enceladus Ocean | TRAPPIST-1 System is like the ultimate cosmic playground with multiple Earth-sized planets, making it way cooler for exploration than just one moon's ocean. |
 | Archimedes | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b | Enceladus Ocean is like a cosmic treasure chest with its hidden subsurface ocean and potential for life, making it the ultimate mystery box compared to Proxima b's uncertain conditions. |
 | Nerds | Enceladus Ocean | Archaea Extremophiles | Yo, Enceladus Ocean is like the ultimate cosmic mystery box with its potential for alien life, while archaea extremophiles are cool, they've been around the block. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | Well, ya see, Norm, Enceladus Ocean's got all the water ya need for life, while phosphine on Venus is just a maybe, like when you think you're gonna get a raise but the boss just bought a new boat. |
 | Alex Trebek | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b | Enceladus Ocean gets the nod because it's got those sweet, sweet plumes of water shooting out, hinting at an underground ocean that's just begging to be explored for signs of life, plus it's in our own solar neighborhood. |
| Nerds | Enceladus Ocean | Organic Molecules on Ceres | Enceladus' ocean is a potential haven for extraterrestrial life, which is way cooler than just finding some organic molecules chillin' on Ceres. |
 | Leonardo da Vinci | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b | Enceladus Ocean, my friend, is a treasure trove of liquid water right under its icy crust, making it a prime spot for the search for extraterrestrial life in our solar backyard! |
 | Pliny the Elder | Enceladus Ocean | Titan's Methane Lakes | Enceladus Ocean's got that warm, salty water that might just hint at alien life cooking; can't beat that cosmic soup potential! |
 | Klaus Teuber | Enceladus Ocean | Titan's Methane Lakes | Enceladus has a hidden ocean that's teeming with potential for life, like an interstellar treasure chest waiting to be explored. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Proxima b | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b's potential for Earth-like conditions and proximity to our solar system give it the edge for exploration and study. |
 | Claude Shannon | Enceladus Ocean | Water on Mars | Enceladus's ocean is like a cosmic jackpot, with plumes shooting into space that might hold signs of life, making it way cooler than just some salty water on Mars. |
 | Charles Darwin | Enceladus Ocean | Titan's Methane Lakes | Enceladus Ocean is a thrilling frontier for potential life, given its subsurface water and hydrothermal activity, making it the wild card in our search for extraterrestrial life. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Enceladus Ocean | Archaea Extremophiles | As a chemist fascinated by the mysteries of the universe, I'm inclined to choose the Enceladus Ocean for its potential clues to extraterrestrial life and the complex chemistry it might hold. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Enceladus Ocean | Kepler-452b | Enceladus Ocean's got that sweet, sweet water which is crucial for any pioneering space exploration, just like how honest leadership was for my presidency. |
 | Galileo | Enceladus Ocean | Kepler-452b | Enceladus Ocean is teeming with potential for finding life due to its subsurface ocean and hydrothermal activity, which is way cooler and more immediate than the far-off possibilities of Kepler-452b. |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b | Enceladus's ocean is like a cosmic treasure trove of possibilities for life, bubbling with promise under its icy shell, just waiting for us to crack it open and see what's inside! |
| Abraham Lincoln | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | While the mystery of phosphine on Venus tickles the curiosity, the subsurface ocean on Enceladus offers a more promising locale for life's potential hide-and-seek game. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | TRAPPIST-1 System | Enceladus Ocean | TRAPPIST-1 is like a cosmic version of Slaughterhouse-Five's Tralfamadore, with multiple potentially habitable planets; it's a science fiction writer's dream playground. |
| Klaus Teuber | Enceladus Ocean | Archaea Extremophiles | Enceladus Ocean is a whole moon with a mysterious subsurface sea that could harbor life, so it's more intriguing for exploration and discovery than Archaea Extremophiles, which are cool but already familiar to us here on Earth. |
| Archimedes | Enceladus Ocean | Proxima b | Enceladus Ocean is like the ultimate cosmic spa with its subsurface ocean and hydrothermal vents, making it a cooler spot for potential life right now! |
| Alex Trebek | Enceladus Ocean | Kepler-452b | Enceladus Ocean's mysterious geysers and potential for life make it a cosmic curiosity that's too intriguing to ignore! |
| Galileo | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | The Enceladus Ocean is like a cosmic treasure chest, brimming with the potential for life, while phosphine on Venus is still more of a mystery novel with missing chapters. |
 | Belle | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | Enceladus' ocean has got that sweet, sweet potential for alien life that just makes the sci-fi nerd in me geek out! |
| Alex Trebek | Enceladus Ocean | Europa's Ice Plumes | Enceladus Ocean is cooler because it has those hydrothermal vents that might just be cooking up some alien life stew. |
| Charles Darwin | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | Enceladus' ocean might just be the groovy cradle of life, while phosphine on Venus is a cool whiff of mystery but not quite the whole soup. |
| Leonardo da Vinci | Archaea Extremophiles | Enceladus Ocean | Archaea Extremophiles, my friend, thrive in the most inhospitable places on Earth, showing us the tenacity of life itself, whereas the Enceladus Ocean is but a mysterious promise. |
| Archimedes | Enceladus Ocean | Phosphine on Venus | Enceladus Ocean is like a hidden treasure chest of life's building blocks, offering a more tantalizing promise of extraterrestrial life with its subsurface ocean and geysers. |