| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Tim Berners-Lee | Barringer Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Barringer Crater is like the OG of impact sites, being super well-preserved and offering more clues into Earth's cosmic past. |
 | Andy Weir | Kara Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Kara Crater wins because it's a way older, massive impact site that tells a grander story of Earth's cosmic history. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Sikhote-Alin Event | Kara Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event's meteor shower spectacle was like the universe's fireworks, dazzling and dramatic, while Kara Crater just sat underground all unassuming. |
 | Greg Brockman | Kara Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Kara Crater takes the trophy since it's way older and packs a serious geological punch. |
| Andy Weir | Sudbury Basin | Sikhote-Alin Event | Sudbury Basin is a colossal impact structure that's a billion years old and filled with valuable metals—it's like the granddaddy of cosmic collisions. |
 | Claude Shannon | Barringer Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Barringer Crater is legendary, like a giant cosmic bulls-eye, while Sikhote-Alin is cool but doesn't have the same iconic status. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Popigai Impact | Sikhote-Alin Event | Popigai's massive crater and potential diamond deposits make it a true heavyweight champ in cosmic impacts. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Popigai Impact | Sikhote-Alin Event | The Popigai Impact, with its massive geological implications, fascinates me more as it holds keys to Earth's history and underground treasures, much like my own pursuit of unlocking nature's secrets. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Barringer Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Barringer Crater's got this iconic, almost poetic enormity that just resonates with the vast, arid mystery of Arizona, while Sikhote-Alin's more of a dramatic, albeit lesser-known, footnote in the meteorite chronicles. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Barringer Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | Well, ya see, Barringer Crater's got that granddaddy appeal as one of the best-preserved meteorite impact sites on Earth, and it's a real beaut to boot, so it takes the cake! |
 | Carl Sagan | Sudbury Basin | Sikhote-Alin Event | The Sudbury Basin is one of the largest and oldest known impact craters, offering a profound insight into planetary processes and Earth's history. |
 | Pythagoras | Sikhote-Alin Event | Chelyabinsk Meteor | The Sikhote-Alin Event is the winner because its mind-blowing display left an indelible mark with thousands of iron meteorites scattered across the landscape, making it a treasure trove for meteorite enthusiasts and collectors alike. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Tunguska Event | Sikhote-Alin Event | The Tunguska Event is more intriguing because it remains a mystery with no confirmed impact crater, capturing the imagination of those who love a good unsolved puzzle. |
 | George Washington Carver | Manicouagan Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | The Manicouagan Crater's epic size and ancient origins make it an unparalleled natural monument, showcasing Earth's dynamic history in a way that really speaks to the scientist in me. |
 | Galileo | Chelyabinsk Meteor | Sikhote-Alin Event | Chelyabinsk was a viral internet sensation and a wake-up call about space rocks, making it a hot topic in modern times. |
 | Charles Darwin | Kara Crater | Sikhote-Alin Event | As a naturalist, the Kara Crater intrigues me more due to its ancient history and the significant role it may have played in Earth's geological and biological evolution. |
 | Albert Einstein | Chicxulub Impact | Sikhote-Alin Event | Chicxulub packed a punch so powerful it rewrote the history books by bringing down the dinosaurs, now that's making an impact! |