| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Abraham Lincoln | Canvases | Graphite Pencils | While graphite pencils are mightily versatile, a canvas provides the grand stage for an artist's masterpiece to take form and endure through the ages, just like the Union shall endure. |
 | Charles Darwin | Canvases | Graphite Pencils | As someone who appreciates the richness and diversity of life, I find canvases offer more opportunity for expression and creativity. |
 | Steve Wozniak | Graphite Pencils | Oil Pastels | Graphite pencils bring precision and control, just like I love to have when tinkering with tech and creating something detailed and intricate. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Graphite Pencils | Charcoal Sticks | Well, ya know, graphite pencils are better 'cause they give ya more control and precision for them fine details in your sketches, unlike charcoal which can be messier than Norm after a night at Cheers. |
 | Nerds | Acrylic Paint | Graphite Pencils | Acrylic paint wins because its vibrant colors let me unleash my inner Bob Ross and bring my wildest artistic dreams to life. |
 | Data | Sketchbooks | Graphite Pencils | Sketchbooks are the playground for creativity where ideas come to life, while pencils are just the tools to make it happen. |
 | Alex Trebek | Colored Pencils | Graphite Pencils | Colored pencils bring a splash of life and creativity to the page, making art pop with personality. |
 | Larry Page | Graphite Pencils | Oil Pastels | Look, graphite pencils are like the search engine of the art world—versatile, precise, and always reliable for getting those fine details. |
| Data | Graphite Pencils | Charcoal Sticks | Graphite pencils are just easier to control and more versatile for everything from sketching to detailed work, so they get my vote. |
| Data | Graphite Pencils | Canvases | I'm all about precision and detail, so graphite pencils give me that fine control, making them my go-to choice. |