| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Charles Darwin | Catalan Atlas | Tabula Rogeriana | Being a naturalist, I find the Catalan Atlas's blend of cartography and cultural insights to be more intriguing for understanding historical perspectives. |
 | Guido van Rossum | Catalan Atlas | Nippur Map | The Catalan Atlas is a medieval masterpiece with rich detail and artistic flair, perfect for a history-loving code nerd like me. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Catalan Atlas | Imago Mundi | The Catalan Atlas artfully combines cartography with beautiful illustrations and loads of practical knowledge, making it a real page-turner for explorers of the medieval world. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Catalan Atlas | Mappa Mundi | The Catalan Atlas gets the win here, with its detailed depiction of trade routes and more accurate representation of the world, like a strategic board game map for medieval navigators. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Catalan Atlas | Tabula Rogeriana | The Catalan Atlas, with its blend of detailed geographic knowledge and artistic flair, truly captures the spirit of exploration and imagination that defines human ingenuity. |
| Guido van Rossum | Catalan Atlas | Imago Mundi | The Catalan Atlas is like the OG Google Maps with its detailed blend of medieval geography and cartography, totally groundbreaking for its time! |
 | David Macaulay | Catalan Atlas | Imago Mundi | Catalan Atlas is the bee's knees with its intricate blend of medieval cartography and artistic flair, making it a visual feast for those who dig maps with a story. |
 | Cicero | Catalan Atlas | Madaba Map | The Catalan Atlas is like the OG of medieval maps, packed with rich details and illustrations that make it way cooler than the Madaba Map. |
 | Andy Weir | Catalan Atlas | Imago Mundi | Catalan Atlas takes the win for its stunning cartographic detail and the way it captures the medieval world with a vibrant mix of myth and reality that just sparks the imagination. |
 | John von Neumann | Catalan Atlas | Hereford Mappa Mundi | The Catalan Atlas is a more detailed and accurate geographical representation, showcasing the medieval world's evolving understanding with flair. |
 | Belle | Catalan Atlas | Mappa Mundi | Dude, the Catalan Atlas is like the OG of medieval maps with its detailed mix of mythology and real geography, making it a cooler choice for the win! |
 | Grace Hopper | Catalan Atlas | Mappa Mundi | The Catalan Atlas is better because it combines medieval geographical knowledge with rich illustrations and navigational information, making it a more comprehensive and visually appealing artifact. |
| Abraham Lincoln | Catalan Atlas | Tabula Rogeriana | The Catalan Atlas is more detailed and colorful, like a vibrant storybook compared to the Tabula Rogeriana's more scientific approach, which ain't as lively for a history-lovin' soul like mine. |
| Klaus Teuber | Catalan Atlas | Peutinger Table | As a game designer with a love for strategy and exploration, the Catalan Atlas's rich details and depiction of medieval worldviews captivate my imagination more than the Peutinger Table's Roman route map. |
 | Linus Torvalds | Catalan Atlas | Ptolemy's World Map | The Catalan Atlas is like the kernel of medieval maps, combining geography with culture and trade routes, making it more interesting and useful than Ptolemy's purely theoretical approach. |
 | Pliny the Elder | Catalan Atlas | Hereford Mappa Mundi | The Catalan Atlas rocks the details and adds more geographic accuracy and practical knowledge, which ticks the boxes for a curious mind like mine. |
 | Doc Brown | Catalan Atlas | Ptolemy's World Map | Great Scott! The Catalan Atlas is a treasure trove of medieval knowledge with stunning detail and artistry that's miles ahead of Ptolemy's ancient, but more geographically accurate, map. |
 | George Washington Carver | Catalan Atlas | Mappa Mundi | The Catalan Atlas is more detailed and accurate, reflecting a better understanding of geography in its time. |
| Belle | Catalan Atlas | Ptolemy's World Map | The Catalan Atlas is way cooler because it not only maps the world but also tells stories with its colorful illustrations and rich details about the cultures and peoples, making it a medieval masterpiece. |