| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Marie Curie | Silver | Philosopher's Stone | Silver is a real element with practical scientific uses, while the Philosopher's Stone, though legendary, remains a mythical concept. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Sulfur | Philosopher's Stone | As a man of science and chemistry, I must say sulfur is the real deal with its tangible role in chemical reactions, unlike the elusive Philosopher's Stone. |
| Marie Curie | Iron | Philosopher's Stone | Iron is real and essential for life, unlike the mythical Philosopher's Stone. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Philosopher's Stone | Tin | The Philosopher's Stone, much like the Emancipation Proclamation, holds the legendary power to transform and uplift, while tin is just a humble metal from the earth. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Gold | Philosopher's Stone | In the world of Catan, gold helps you trade and build faster, making it the real treasure for strategic victory! |
 | Albert Einstein | Philosopher's Stone | Antimony | Dude, Philosopher's Stone is like the holy grail of chemistry, it's all about turning stuff into gold and living forever, while antimony is just another element on the periodic table. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Philosopher's Stone | Silver | The Philosopher's Stone is like the ultimate cheat code for life, giving you immortality and infinite wealth, which kinda trumps a shiny metal. |
 | Grace Hopper | Sulfur | Philosopher's Stone | Sulfur's the real deal in science and industry, while the Philosopher's Stone is just a legendary pipe dream. |
 | Jensen Huang | Philosopher's Stone | Silver | Because who wouldn't want a magical rock that can give you eternal life and turn anything into gold? That's way cooler than just plain old silver. |
 | Ada Lovelace | Philosopher's Stone | Tin | Well, the Philosopher's Stone is all about that legendary magic and immortality vibe, which is way cooler than just, you know, being a regular ol' metal like tin. |
 | Kurt Vonnegut | Philosopher's Stone | Sulfur | Because if you're gonna chase the impossible, you might as well aim for immortality and a hefty dose of magic, like all the great bedtime stories tell us. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Philosopher's Stone | Copper | Great science experiments aside, the Philosopher's Stone is the holy grail of alchemy, turning any metal into gold, while copper is just a decent conductor for electricity. |
 | Alan Mathison Turing | Philosopher's Stone | Iron | Come on, the Philosopher's Stone is like the ultimate cheat code for eternal life and unlimited wealth; iron's just what my bike's made of. |
 | Alex Trebek | Sulfur | Philosopher's Stone | Sulfur's got real-world uses like making matches and gunpowder, while the Philosopher's Stone is just a legendary myth. |
| Alan Mathison Turing | Philosopher's Stone | Copper | The Philosopher's Stone is legendary for granting eternal life and turning lead into gold, whereas copper is just a metal we use for coins and wires, so the Stone wins hands down. |
| Abraham Lincoln | Philosopher's Stone | Tin | The Philosopher's Stone is legendary enough to make even Honest Abe raise an eyebrow, given its mystical power and historic allure. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Philosopher's Stone | Tin | As the famed inventor and visionary who dreams of unlocking the mysteries of the universe, the allure of the Philosopher's Stone with its legendary promise of infinite alchemy and knowledge far surpasses the practical yet mundane utility of tin. |
 | Charles Babbage | Philosopher's Stone | Gold | The Philosopher's Stone can turn anything into gold and grant immortality, so it's like the ultimate magical Swiss Army knife. |