| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Andy Weir | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 offers superior craftsmanship and a richer sound that's perfect for an audiophile like me who appreciates quality and nuance. |
 | Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Seagull S6 | Yamaha LL16 | If you dig a warm, rich tone with an excellent price-to-quality ratio, the Seagull S6 is your jam. |
| Dr. Frederick Frankenstein | Seagull S6 | Fender CD-60 | The Seagull S6 has killer sound quality and craftsmanship, making it a top pick for serious strummers like myself. |
 | Guglielmo Marconi | Taylor 814ce | Seagull S6 | The Taylor 814ce has that sweet, rich sound and top-notch craftsmanship that just sings, making it a standout for serious players. |
 | Copernicus | Yamaha LL16 | Seagull S6 | The Yamaha LL16 has that rich, full sound and superior craftsmanship that just makes it a standout, especially for players who appreciate top-notch quality. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like a symphony in your hands, delivering rich, resonant tones that make it the top pick for seasoned musicians craving depth and power. |
 | Carl Sagan | Seagull S6 | Guild D-55 | The Seagull S6 offers incredible value and a warm, rich sound that's perfect for those who appreciate the beauty in simplicity and craftsmanship. |
 | Charles Babbage | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like a Rolls Royce of guitars, with its rich sound and top-notch craftsmanship, it just sings, man. |
 | Antoine Lavoisier | Seagull S6 | Fender CD-60 | The Seagull S6 has a richer sound and better build quality, making it the go-to choice for any serious strummer or picker. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Seagull S6 | Fender CD-60 | The Seagull S6 rocks with its solid cedar top and richer tone, making it a sweet choice for serious musicians. |
 | Cicero | Seagull S6 | Fender CD-60 | The Seagull S6 has a richer sound and better craftsmanship that makes it worth the extra bucks for anyone serious about their strumming game. |
 | Grace Hopper | Seagull S6 | Takamine GD93 | The Seagull S6 rocks with its mellow tone and solid build, making it perfect for those who want a great sounding acoustic without breaking the bank. |
 | Socrates | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like the Rolls Royce of guitars, with its rich tone and craftsmanship that's just on another level. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Collings OM2H | Seagull S6 | The Collings OM2H is a handcrafted masterpiece with exquisite tone and craftsmanship that's unmatched. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Martin D-28 | Seagull S6 | The Martin D-28 is like the OG of guitars, with its legendary sound and craftsmanship that's hard to beat if you're looking for that classic tone. |
| Nikola Tesla | Collings OM2H | Seagull S6 | If you're chasing that premium sound and craftsmanship, the Collings OM2H is the ace of spades in the guitar world. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | Well, ya see, the Guild D-55 is like the Cadillac of guitars with its rich history and craftsmanship, so it's hard to beat that kind of pedigree. |
 | Buckminster Fuller | Seagull S6 | Yamaha LL16 | The Seagull S6's unique Canadian craftsmanship and warm sound make it a harmonious choice for folksy vibes. |
 | David Foster Wallace | Seagull S6 | Takamine GD93 | The Seagull S6's warm, resonant sound and solid cedar top make it a no-brainer for anyone serious about strumming up some rich, soulful tunes. |
 | Albert Einstein | Seagull S6 | Breedlove Pursuit | The Seagull S6 has that sweet, rich sound and a solid build that's perfect for strumming those Einstein-level ideas into reality. |
| Grace Hopper | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like the Cadillac of guitars, with top-notch build quality and rich, resonant tones that make it stand out for serious players. |