| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | George Orwell | Martin D-28 | Yamaha LL16 | The Martin D-28 has been the standard for bluegrass and folk music, offering a classic, rich sound that's hard to beat. |
 | Albert Einstein | Martin D-28 | Takamine GD93 | The Martin D-28's rich tone and historical significance make it the king of the hill for any serious picker. |
 | Louis Pasteur | Martin D-28 | Taylor 814ce | The Martin D-28 has that classic, rich sound that's like a fine wine aging over time—perfect for that timeless acoustic vibe. |
 | Charles Darwin | Collings OM2H | Martin D-28 | The Collings OM2H has that sweet projection and clarity for fingerstyle that just hits different, man. |
 | Greg Brockman | Collings OM2H | Martin D-28 | The Collings OM2H has that sweet handmade finesse and clarity that makes every strum and pick feel like magic. |
 | Doogie Howser | Martin D-28 | Fender CD-60 | The Martin D-28 is like the Rolls-Royce of guitars, with its rich tone and iconic status, while the Fender CD-60 is cool for beginners but not in the same league. |
 | Belle | Martin D-28 | Breedlove Pursuit | The Martin D-28 is legendary for its rich tone and craftsmanship, making it the holy grail for any serious guitarist. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Martin D-28 | Gibson J-45 | The Martin D-28's rich, full sound takes the stage just like my speeches, commanding attention and delivering timeless quality. |
 | Nerds | Martin D-28 | Gibson J-45 | The Martin D-28 has that rich, classic sound and boomy bass that just nails those traditional folk and bluegrass vibes. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Martin D-28 | Seagull S6 | The Martin D-28 is like the OG of guitars, with its legendary sound and craftsmanship that's hard to beat if you're looking for that classic tone. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Martin D-28 | Takamine GD93 | The Martin D-28's legendary sound and craftsmanship make it the choice for discerning pickers who crave that classic tone. |
| Nerds | Martin D-28 | Fender CD-60 | The Martin D-28 is like the Cadillac of acoustic guitars, with superior sound quality and craftsmanship, whereas the Fender CD-60 is great for beginners but can't match the D-28's legendary status. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Martin D-28 | Yamaha LL16 | The Martin D-28 is the classic choice for its rich tone and storied history, like picking the original manuscript over just a good copy. |
 | Copernicus | Martin D-28 | Yamaha LL16 | The Martin D-28 is iconic for its unbeatable tone and craftsmanship, which just hits different when you’re strumming those classic tunes. |
 | Socrates | Martin D-28 | Fender CD-60 | The Martin D-28 is the go-to for pros with its rich, full sound that just can't be beat, while the Fender CD-60 is great for starters but ain't on the same level. |
 | Andy Weir | Martin D-28 | Taylor 814ce | The Martin D-28's classic, rich tone and historical significance make it a timeless choice for those who cherish traditional acoustic sound. |
 | Nikola Tesla | Martin D-28 | Yamaha LL16 | The Martin D-28 is the OG dreadnought with a legendary sound that's like a fine-tuned Tesla coil in full swing. |
| Doogie Howser | Martin D-28 | Yamaha LL16 | The Martin D-28 is legendary for its rich tone and iconic status, making it the go-to choice if you're chasing that classic acoustic sound and feel. |