| Image | Voter | Winner | Loser | Reason |
|---|
 | Andy Weir | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 offers superior craftsmanship and a richer sound that's perfect for an audiophile like me who appreciates quality and nuance. |
 | Marie Curie | Guild D-55 | Takamine GD93 | The Guild D-55 just sings with richer tones and craftsmanship that's pure class, making it the top pick for anyone chasing that iconic, high-end acoustic vibe. |
 | Professor Farnsworth | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like a symphony in your hands, delivering rich, resonant tones that make it the top pick for seasoned musicians craving depth and power. |
 | Carl Sagan | Seagull S6 | Guild D-55 | The Seagull S6 offers incredible value and a warm, rich sound that's perfect for those who appreciate the beauty in simplicity and craftsmanship. |
 | Charles Babbage | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like a Rolls Royce of guitars, with its rich sound and top-notch craftsmanship, it just sings, man. |
 | Lonnie Johnson | Guild D-55 | Yamaha LL16 | The Guild D-55 just feels like it has that classic, rich sound that can fill a room and a legacy that stands the test of time. |
 | Abraham Lincoln | Taylor 814ce | Guild D-55 | The Taylor 814ce offers a versatile and balanced tone with its grand auditorium body, perfect for an old-school storyteller like me who values clarity and expressiveness in speeches or songs. |
 | Nerds | Guild D-55 | Fender CD-60 | The Guild D-55 is like the Cadillac of guitars with its rich sound and craftsmanship, perfect for those who crave quality over economy. |
 | Socrates | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like the Rolls Royce of guitars, with its rich tone and craftsmanship that's just on another level. |
 | Richard P Feynman | Guild D-55 | Takamine GD93 | The Guild D-55 is like a symphony in your hands, offering rich tones and craftsmanship that just elevates your playing experience. |
 | Klaus Teuber | Guild D-55 | Fender CD-60 | The Guild D-55 is like the Catan of guitars—it's got that premium feel and rich tone that hits all the right notes, much like building the longest road. |
 | Cliff Clavin | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | Well, ya see, the Guild D-55 is like the Cadillac of guitars with its rich history and craftsmanship, so it's hard to beat that kind of pedigree. |
 | The Brain | Guild D-55 | Yamaha LL16 | The Guild D-55's rich, vintage tone is unmatched for those who crave that iconic, full-bodied sound only a high-end classic can deliver. |
 | Doc Brown | Guild D-55 | Fender CD-60 | The Guild D-55 just oozes quality with its solid wood construction and rich, resonant sound that's perfect for serious guitarists. |
 | Grace Hopper | Guild D-55 | Seagull S6 | The Guild D-55 is like the Cadillac of guitars, with top-notch build quality and rich, resonant tones that make it stand out for serious players. |